September 19, 2018
| 1 | Joey Epstein | Johns Hopkins | Landon School |
| 2 | Jacob Kelly | North Carolina | Calvert Hall College High School |
| 3 | John John Lombardi | Cornell | Salisbury School |
| 4 | Matt Brandau | Yale | Boys Latin School of Maryland |
| 5 | Griffin Cook | Syracuse | Jamesville Dewitt High School |
| 6 | Payton Cormier | Virginia | Oakville Trafalgar High School |
| 7 | Nicky Solomon | North Carolina | Centennial High School |
| 8 | Xander Dickson | Virginia | Brunswick School |
| 9 | Brian Cameron | North Carolina | Bishop Guertin High School |
| 10 | Jack Myers | Ohio State | Gonzaga College High School |
| 11 | Drew Erickson | Denver | San Ramon Valley High School |
| 12 | George Wichelns | Maryland | Connetquot High School |
| 13 | Nate Buller | Penn State | Landon School |
| 14 | Dylan Gergar | Penn | Severn School |
| 15 | Beau Pederson | Princeton | Park City High School |
| 16 | Peter Thompson | Georgetown | Detroit Catholic Central High School |
| 17 | Ramsey McCreary | Notre Dame | The Woodlands High School |
| 18 | Jack Traynor | Penn State | Malvern Preparatory School |
| 19 | Billy Coyle | Cornell | The Hill Academy |
| 20 | Dylan Watson | Georgetown | The Hill Academy |
| 21 | Brady McDermott | Yale | Brighton High School |
| 22 | Sam Handley | Penn | Jesuit High School |
| 23 | Ross Pridemore | Loyola | Victor Senior High School |
| 24 | Brian Reda | Fairfield | Pleasantville High School |
