| RedFromMI | FanLax Computer | ||
| 1 | Lindenwood (MO) | Lindenwood | |
| 2 | UIndy | Queens | |
| 3 | Queens (NC) | Limestone | |
| 4 | Le Moyne | Roberts Wesleyan | |
| 5 | West Chester | West Chester | |
| 6 | Seton Hill | Mount Olive | |
| 7 | Regis (CO) | Grand Valley State | |
| 8 | Mount Olive | Le Moyne | |
| 9 | Roberts Wesleyan | Mercy | |
| 10 | Limestone | Rollins | |
| 11 | Mercy | Seton Hill | |
| 12 | Grand Valley St. | Florida Southern | |
| 13 | Tampa | Davenport | |
| 14 | East Stroudsburg | Tampa | |
| 15 | Davenport | Wingate | |
| 16 | Wingate | Assumption | |
| 17 | McKendree | Bentley | |
| 18 | Fla. Southern | East Stroudsburg | |
| 19 | Bentley | McKendree | |
| 20 | Alabama Huntsville | Pace | |
| 21 | Georgian Court | UIndy | |
| 22 | Belmont Abbey | Jefferson | |
| 23 | Lee | Georgian Court | |
| 24 | Rollins | Mercyhurst | |
| 25 | Colorado Mesa | Saint Anselm |
