The Best Goalie of all time D1

[Mr3Putt]

Ive been around. Ok? Schmoiler, Locassio , Kevin Mahon, Larry Quinn, Rick Blick, Van Arsdale, Tommy Sears, Tillman Johnson , Quint Kessinich, Palumb, Weirmann, Malloy, Dan Mackessey…….. I think Liam Entenamann is possibly the greatest of all time. And I don’t care about the desserts: International play, PLL - stuff . Why ? Because no one cares about it. And, either do I!

[DocBarrister]

Ive been around. Ok? Schmoiler, Locassio , Kevin Mahon, Larry Quinn, Rick Blick, Van Arsdale, Tommy Sears, Tillman Johnson , Quint Kessinich, Palumb, Weirmann, Malloy, Dan Mackessey…….. I think Liam Entenamann is possibly the greatest of all time. And I don’t care about the deserts- International play, PLL - stuff . Why ? Because no one cares about it. And, either do I!

Uh, ever hear of some guy named Mike Federico?

DocBarrister

[Mr3Putt]

Yes ! I missed one Doc, you are correct, an all timer.

[DocBarrister]

Yes ! I missed one Doc, you are correct, an all timer.

That’s ok! I am impressed that you actually (appropriately) included Quint on the list.

DocBarrister

[jrn19]

Of the last few decades, it's Tillman Johnson

Previous few, Larry Quinn and Bacigalupo have pretty much unimpeachable resumes but there were a lot of great ones

Entenmann was very good, great throughout his career at points and particularly in the '23 tournament. But there were others right there with them; and he wasn't 03 tournament Johnson at any point

[44WeWantMore]

If Matt Russell had Piggy's or LQ's defense in front of him, he would have been on your list.

Or even QK's defense.

[LaxPundit07]

Of the last few decades, it's Tillman Johnson

Previous few, Larry Quinn and Bacigalupo have pretty much unimpeachable resumes but there were a lot of great ones

Entenmann was very good, great throughout his career at points and particularly in the '23 tournament. But there were others right there with them; and he wasn't 03 tournament Johnson at any point

Mickey Jarboe

[Mr3Putt]

Of the last few decades, it's Tillman Johnson

Previous few, Larry Quinn and Bacigalupo have pretty much unimpeachable resumes but there were a lot of great ones

Entenmann was very good, great throughout his career at points and particularly in the '23 tournament. But there were others right there with them; and he wasn't 03 tournament Johnson at any point

Mickey Jarboe

Mickey was wonderful. And a super person! But you have to incorporated into the NCAA tournament!

[Mr3Putt]

Yes ! I missed one Doc, you are correct, an all timer.

That’s ok! I am impressed that you actually (appropriately) included Quint on the list.

DocBarrister

Doc I love Larry & Quint! Great
People.

[Mr3Putt]

Of the last few decades, it's Tillman Johnson

Previous few, Larry Quinn and Bacigalupo have pretty much unimpeachable resumes but there were a lot of great ones

Entenmann was very good, great throughout his career at points and particularly in the '23 tournament. But there were others right there with them; and he wasn't 03 tournament Johnson at any point

There u go! I forgot Scott , Bacigalupo is must do! I forgot him. An all timer. Here’s to St Paul’s .

[Comeonman]

Ive been around. Ok? Schmoiler, Locassio , Kevin Mahon, Larry Quinn, Rick Blick, Van Arsdale, Tommy Sears, Tillman Johnson , Quint Kessinich, Palumb, Weirmann, Malloy, Dan Mackessey…….. I think Liam Entenamann is possibly the greatest of all time. And I don’t care about the desserts: International play, PLL - stuff . Why ? Because no one cares about it. And, either do I!

Not even close. Played for some great teams, but he has a ton of sub 50% games in his career and his save percentage over that span is somewhere around only 57% with goals against average over 9. Too inconsistent.

[Mr3Putt]

Ive been around. Ok? Schmoiler, Locassio , Kevin Mahon, Larry Quinn, Rick Blick, Van Arsdale, Tommy Sears, Tillman Johnson , Quint Kessinich, Palumb, Weirmann, Malloy, Dan Mackessey…….. I think Liam Entenamann is possibly the greatest of all time. And I don’t care about the desserts: International play, PLL - stuff . Why ? Because no one cares about it. And, either do I!

Not even close. Played for some great teams, but he has a ton of sub 50% games in his career and his save percentage over that span is somewhere around only 57% with goals against average over 9. Too inconsistent.

Easy, you had a great year. GT had been good for lacrosse, go sit down.

[Mr3Putt]

Ive been around. Ok? Schmoiler, Locassio , Kevin Mahon, Larry Quinn, Rick Blick, Van Arsdale, Tommy Sears, Tillman Johnson , Quint Kessinich, Palumb, Weirmann, Malloy, Dan Mackessey…….. I think Liam Entenamann is possibly the greatest of all time. And I don’t care about the desserts: International play, PLL - stuff . Why ? Because no one cares about it. And, either do I!

Not even close. Played for some great teams, but he has a ton of sub 50% games in his career and his save percentage over that span is somewhere around only 57% with goals against average over 9. Too inconsistent.

Easy, you had a great year. GT had been good for lacrosse, go sit down. Let me guess ? Dc or Philly area?

[wgdsr]

schmioler, locasio, sheehan, bacigalupo, johnson, from old guard. don't know 70's to early-early 80's. maybe beardmore and doc. newer guys are tougher. mostly because the ball comes so fast, shot fakes, etc. some ridiculous goalies, but quite a few of them seem on equal footing, but only bc the job's so tough. entenmann's in that group.

[Mr3Putt]

schmioler, locasio, sheehan, bacigalupo, johnson, from old guard. don't know 70's to early-early 80's. maybe beardmore and doc. newer guys are tougher. mostly because the ball comes so fast, shot fakes, etc. some ridiculous goalies, but quite a few of them seem on equal footing, but only bc the job's so tough. entenmann's in that group.

I enjoyed Beardmore , but that was more about the extra curricular. Running out of the cage, and making special saves

[BlueJaySince1947]

Larry Quinn hands down...was POY for two consecutive seasons.

[Finster]

Ive been around. Ok? Schmoiler, Locassio , Kevin Mahon, Larry Quinn, Rick Blick, Van Arsdale, Tommy Sears, Tillman Johnson , Quint Kessinich, Palumb, Weirmann, Malloy, Dan Mackessey…….. I think Liam Entenamann is possibly the greatest of all time. And I don’t care about the desserts: International play, PLL - stuff . Why ? Because no one cares about it. And, either do I!

Lacrosse has so many fans who demand superlative labels. ^^^

Entenmann’s a great goalie, but he wasn’t even top-5 in D1 this year. Slow your roll.

[BlueJaySince1947]

schmioler, locasio, sheehan, bacigalupo, johnson, from old guard. don't know 70's to early-early 80's. maybe beardmore and doc. newer guys are tougher. mostly because the ball comes so fast, shot fakes, etc. some ridiculous goalies, but quite a few of them seem on equal footing, but only bc the job's so tough. entenmann's in that group.

I enjoyed Beardmore , but that was more about the extra curricular. Running out of the cage, and making special saves

He was quite a Hot Dog with his runs down field.
But...in the playoffs against the Jays in 1987 Don Zimmerman had him decked when he started his antics.
Jays won against what was then called the greatest Twerps team ever...great fun.

[Mr3Putt]

Ive been around. Ok? Schmoiler, Locassio , Kevin Mahon, Larry Quinn, Rick Blick, Van Arsdale, Tommy Sears, Tillman Johnson , Quint Kessinich, Palumb, Weirmann, Malloy, Dan Mackessey…….. I think Liam Entenamann is possibly the greatest of all time. And I don’t care about the desserts: International play, PLL - stuff . Why ? Because no one cares about it. And, either do I!

It’s simple, look at your posts. MD had a wonderful run. Ajax Zap wasn’t going do anything today . Tillman squeezed all the juice he could out of this team. But your post is typical


Lacrosse has so many fans who demand superlative labels. ^^^

Entenmann’s a great goalie, but he wasn’t even top-5 in D1 this year. Slow your roll.

[Mr3Putt]

Larry Quinn hands down...was POY for two consecutive seasons.

When I break down goalies I always go back to Larry. . I agree. But this guys is in the conversation. So what was Larry’s specialty? LENGTH! Liam Eentenamnn is is in the conversation.