Page 43 of 92
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:33 am
by MDlaxfan76
Well, if we're done with the personal insults and emojis, it does seem to me that right wing media is doing its darnedest to paint the Biden Admin, specifically the State Dept as some sort of evil doers in the ongoing saga of getting Americans and allies out of Afghanistan.
First we have cradle's assertion, made by Fox and repeated by the NY Post, that Rick Clay (raising money for rescue efforts) and two unnamed private people say that the State Dept is slow walking specific approvals for individuals (vetting) and thus, some flights that might have happened, haven't.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... fghanistan
Might have some truth (if this was a GOP Admin anyone doubt that Fox and NYP would be claiming that the vetting was necessary???);...or is it because the Taliban are actually the ones holding up the planes from leaving? much more likely...
https://www.albawaba.com/news/why-doesn ... an-1445502
Then we have shortly within 24 hours of that story, another claiming that a rescue which the State Dept says they helped facilitate and is applauding, they are somehow claiming too much credit.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... -organizer
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:41 am
by kramerica.inc
To add more clarification-
The report was originally reported by Reuters.
https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-paci ... 021-09-05/
The right wing media picked up on it. The left wing, not so much.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:10 am
by cradleandshoot
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:33 am
Well, if we're done with the personal insults and emojis, it does seem to me that right wing media is doing its darnedest to paint the Biden Admin, specifically the State Dept as some sort of evil doers in the ongoing saga of getting Americans and allies out of Afghanistan.
First we have cradle's assertion, made by Fox and repeated by the NY Post, that Rick Clay (raising money for rescue efforts) and two unnamed private people say that the State Dept is slow walking specific approvals for individuals (vetting) and thus, some flights that might have happened, haven't.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... fghanistan
Might have some truth (if this was a GOP Admin anyone doubt that Fox and NYP would be claiming that the vetting was necessary???);...or is it because the Taliban are actually the ones holding up the planes from leaving? much more likely...
https://www.albawaba.com/news/why-doesn ... an-1445502
Then we have shortly within 24 hours of that story, another claiming that a rescue which the State Dept says they helped facilitate and is applauding, they are somehow claiming too much credit.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... -organizer
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
Bidens decision to leave Afghanistan was the right decision. How Biden chose to implement that decision will go down in history as a monumental failure of epic proportions. It will never be compared to Dunkirk. I would like to know whose advice Biden was following? I have been informed here on this forum that I'm not that smart. I'm smart enough to know then when Bagram Airfield was abandoned overnight in the same manner the Colts left Baltimore the chitstorm was well under way. That brings up one more question that I hope some congressional investigative committee asks... Who made that idiotic decision?
The US exit from Afghanistan should have been a highlight of his 1st year. This is a classic example of grasping defeat from the jaws of victory. If any of you folks are paying attention those 2022 Democrats up for reelection are waiting their turn in line to throw Joe under the bus. I heard a blurb on the news this morning that even Richard Blumenthal is ticked off how this cluster fudge was implemented. Democrats know when and how to distance themselves from a disaster.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:25 am
by kramerica.inc
cradleandshoot wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:10 am
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:33 am
Well, if we're done with the personal insults and emojis, it does seem to me that right wing media is doing its darnedest to paint the Biden Admin, specifically the State Dept as some sort of evil doers in the ongoing saga of getting Americans and allies out of Afghanistan.
First we have cradle's assertion, made by Fox and repeated by the NY Post, that Rick Clay (raising money for rescue efforts) and two unnamed private people say that the State Dept is slow walking specific approvals for individuals (vetting) and thus, some flights that might have happened, haven't.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... fghanistan
Might have some truth (if this was a GOP Admin anyone doubt that Fox and NYP would be claiming that the vetting was necessary???);...or is it because the Taliban are actually the ones holding up the planes from leaving? much more likely...
https://www.albawaba.com/news/why-doesn ... an-1445502
Then we have shortly within 24 hours of that story, another claiming that a rescue which the State Dept says they helped facilitate and is applauding, they are somehow claiming too much credit.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... -organizer
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
Bidens decision to leave Afghanistan was the right decision. How Biden chose to implement that decision will go down in history as a monumental failure of epic proportions. It will never be compared to Dunkirk. I would like to know whose advice Biden was following? I have been informed here on this forum that I'm not that smart. I'm smart enough to know then when Bagram Airfield was abandoned overnight in the same manner the Colts left Baltimore the chitstorm was well under way. That brings up one more question that I hope some congressional investigative committee asks... Who made that idiotic decision?
The US exit from Afghanistan should have been a highlight of his 1st year. This is a classic example of grasping defeat from the jaws of victory. If any of you folks are paying attention those 2022 Democrats up for reelection are waiting their turn in line to throw Joe under the bus. I heard a blurb on the news this morning that even Richard Blumenthal is ticked off how this cluster fudge was implemented. Democrats know when and how to distance themselves from a disaster.
The difference is the Colts actually packed up and took their sh-it (and people) with them.
If you know anything about military logistics and the amount of time that it takes to leave ANYWHERE, this was such a poorly planned decision. If this was a corner Trump painted Biden into, it should have been job 1 since day 1 of his term. but it was clearly a surprise to them or a poorly thought out last minute decision.
And as you say, who made the decision? Not because it will fix anything, but please make sure this person (or people) STOPS advising the president of the USofA. Trump used to get skewered about the "Best People" he hired. What dunderhead was advising Biden on this?
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:25 am
by Farfromgeneva
You have no credibility here which is why they aren’t listening.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:35 am
by Brooklyn
MDLaxFan,
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
Republicans. Their double standards are to be expected. Had it been tRump who saved 124,000 Afghan traitors without the Taliban firing a bullet the right wingers would be praising him to no end.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:49 am
by youthathletics
Brooklyn wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:35 am
MDLaxFan,
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
Republicans. Their double standards are to be expected. Had it been tRump who saved 124,000 Afghan traitors without the Taliban firing a bullet the right wingers would be praising him to no end.
....you forgot your empathy AND sympathy, at the door, yet again, considering 13 US Service Members died in the process of Biden's Cluster FK. Nice try, to change the narrative by saying not a bullet was fired.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 12:35 pm
by MDlaxfan76
youthathletics wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:49 am
Brooklyn wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:35 am
MDLaxFan,
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
Republicans. Their double standards are to be expected. Had it been tRump who saved 124,000 Afghan traitors without the Taliban firing a bullet the right wingers would be praising him to no end.
....you forgot your empathy AND sympathy, at the door, yet again, considering 13 US Service Members died in the process of Biden's Cluster FK. Nice try, to change the narrative by saying not a bullet was fired.
ISIS-K not Taliban
Brooklyn is correct about the astounding level of hypocrisy from the right.
But I object again and again to the tone, much less the label traitor for the people desperate to make better Afghanistan
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 12:58 pm
by Brooklyn
youthathletics wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:49 am
....you forgot your empathy AND sympathy, at the door, yet again, considering 13 US Service Members died in the process of Biden's Cluster FK. Nice try, to change the narrative by saying not a bullet was fired.
The bomb wasn't planted by the Taliban just in case you didn't know it. Had it been them they could have planted a thousand bombs and killed off far many more.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 1:03 pm
by Brooklyn
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 12:35 pm
ISIS-K not Taliban
Brooklyn is correct about the astounding level of hypocrisy from the right.
But I object again and again to the tone, much less the label
traitor for the people desperate to make better Afghanistan
In their country their collaboration with the invading enemies who killed 100,000 of their countrymen it's called treason. If an invader entered the USA and collaborators helped them kill that many Americans, what would you call them? Just for the record, I would call them traitors and would happily attend their neck tie party at the scaffold.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 1:11 pm
by cradleandshoot
kramerica.inc wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:25 am
cradleandshoot wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:10 am
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:33 am
Well, if we're done with the personal insults and emojis, it does seem to me that right wing media is doing its darnedest to paint the Biden Admin, specifically the State Dept as some sort of evil doers in the ongoing saga of getting Americans and allies out of Afghanistan.
First we have cradle's assertion, made by Fox and repeated by the NY Post, that Rick Clay (raising money for rescue efforts) and two unnamed private people say that the State Dept is slow walking specific approvals for individuals (vetting) and thus, some flights that might have happened, haven't.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... fghanistan
Might have some truth (if this was a GOP Admin anyone doubt that Fox and NYP would be claiming that the vetting was necessary???);...or is it because the Taliban are actually the ones holding up the planes from leaving? much more likely...
https://www.albawaba.com/news/why-doesn ... an-1445502
Then we have shortly within 24 hours of that story, another claiming that a rescue which the State Dept says they helped facilitate and is applauding, they are somehow claiming too much credit.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... -organizer
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
Bidens decision to leave Afghanistan was the right decision. How Biden chose to implement that decision will go down in history as a monumental failure of epic proportions. It will never be compared to Dunkirk. I would like to know whose advice Biden was following? I have been informed here on this forum that I'm not that smart. I'm smart enough to know then when Bagram Airfield was abandoned overnight in the same manner the Colts left Baltimore the chitstorm was well under way. That brings up one more question that I hope some congressional investigative committee asks... Who made that idiotic decision?
The US exit from Afghanistan should have been a highlight of his 1st year. This is a classic example of grasping defeat from the jaws of victory. If any of you folks are paying attention those 2022 Democrats up for reelection are waiting their turn in line to throw Joe under the bus. I heard a blurb on the news this morning that even Richard Blumenthal is ticked off how this cluster fudge was implemented. Democrats know when and how to distance themselves from a disaster.
The difference is the Colts actually packed up and took their sh-it (and people) with them.
If you know anything about military logistics and the amount of time that it takes to leave ANYWHERE, this was such a poorly planned decision. If this was a corner Trump painted Biden into, it should have been job 1 since day 1 of his term. but it was clearly a surprise to them or a poorly thought out last minute decision.
And as you say, who made the decision? Not because it will fix anything, but please make sure this person (or people) STOPS advising the president of the USofA. Trump used to get skewered about the "Best People" he hired. What dunderhead was advising Biden on this?
+1 well said
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 1:42 pm
by MDlaxfan76
Brooklyn wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 1:03 pm
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 12:35 pm
ISIS-K not Taliban
Brooklyn is correct about the astounding level of hypocrisy from the right.
But I object again and again to the tone, much less the label
traitor for the people desperate to make better Afghanistan
In their country their collaboration with the invading enemies who killed 100,000 of their countrymen it's called treason. If an invader entered the USA and collaborators helped them kill that many Americans, what would you call them? Just for the record, I would call them traitors and would happily attend their neck tie party at the scaffold.
So, too would our Founding Fathers have been hanged for "treason" had they been caught by the British. And we had French assistance.
Let's just say that we disagree strenuously.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:34 pm
by old salt
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:33 am
Well, if we're done with the personal insults and emojis, it does seem to me that right wing media is doing its darnedest to paint the Biden Admin, specifically the State Dept as some sort of evil doers in the ongoing saga of getting Americans and allies out of Afghanistan.
First we have cradle's assertion, made by Fox and repeated by the NY Post, that Rick Clay (raising money for rescue efforts) and two unnamed private people say that the State Dept is slow walking specific approvals for individuals (vetting) and thus, some flights that might have happened, haven't.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... fghanistan
Might have some truth (if this was a GOP Admin anyone doubt that Fox and NYP would be claiming that the vetting was necessary???);...or is it because the Taliban are actually the ones holding up the planes from leaving? much more likely...
https://www.albawaba.com/news/why-doesn ... an-1445502
Then we have shortly within 24 hours of that story, another claiming that a rescue which the State Dept says they helped facilitate and is applauding, they are somehow claiming too much credit.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... -organizer
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
You do realize you are addressing 2 different rescue missions ?
In the overland rescue that succeeded, the group that organized, funded & facilitated the rescue is complaining that the State Dept is taking credit for the efforts of the volunteer group.
For the air recuse flights trapped in Mazir-I-Sharif, the State Dept is giving an evasive none answer. Of course we don't have anyone there to screen & verify the passengers & issue travel documents. This is an emergency air lift of evacuees from a war zone. The US State Dept has Embassy staff in Doha to coordinate these matters with the Qatari & Taliban officials there. Our SecState & SecDef are even there. All that should be reqd is for the US to assure the Qataris that all the passengers without the necessary documents will be immediately transported to the US. That should allow Qatar to issue diplomatic clearance for the flights to enter Qatar. All that's needed prior to departure is a thorough physical security check of the passengers & baggage. The US needs to guarantee that we will maintain custody of any passengers without the required travel documents & transport them to the US without extended delay for processing.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:39 pm
by MDlaxfan76
old salt wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:34 pm
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:33 am
Well, if we're done with the personal insults and emojis, it does seem to me that right wing media is doing its darnedest to paint the Biden Admin, specifically the State Dept as some sort of evil doers in the ongoing saga of getting Americans and allies out of Afghanistan.
First we have cradle's assertion, made by Fox and repeated by the NY Post, that Rick Clay (raising money for rescue efforts) and two unnamed private people say that the State Dept is slow walking specific approvals for individuals (vetting) and thus, some flights that might have happened, haven't.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... fghanistan
Might have some truth (if this was a GOP Admin anyone doubt that Fox and NYP would be claiming that the vetting was necessary???);...or is it because the Taliban are actually the ones holding up the planes from leaving? much more likely...
https://www.albawaba.com/news/why-doesn ... an-1445502
Then we have shortly within 24 hours of that story, another claiming that a rescue which the State Dept says they helped facilitate and is applauding, they are somehow claiming too much credit.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... -organizer
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
You do realize you are addressing 2 different rescue missions ?
In the overland rescue that succeeded, the group that organized, funded & facilitated the rescue is complaining that the State Dept is taking credit for the efforts of the volunteer group.
For the air recuse flights trapped in Mazir-I-Sharif, the State Dept is giving an evasive none answer. Of course we don't have anyone there to screen & verify the passengers & issue travel documents. This is an emergency air lift of evacuees from a war zone. The US State Dept has Embassy staff in Doha to coordinate these matters with the Qatari & Taliban officials there. Our SecState & SecDef are even there. All that should be reqd is for the US to assure the Qataris that all the passengers without the necessary documents will be immediately transported to the US. That should allow Qatar to issue diplomatic clearance for the flights to enter Qatar. All that's needed prior to departure is a thorough physical security check of the passengers & baggage. The US needs to assure that we will maintain custody of any passengers without the required travel documents & transport them to the US without extended delay for processing.
Of course I realize these are two different rescue efforts; the common denominator is Fox and others attacking the Biden Admin, specifically State dept. One for not doing enough (supposedly...or is that the Taliban are preventing departure), the other for taking credit for having a success happen.
There's going to be an incessant amount of these attacks on the Biden Admin. Some may actually be deserved, but they all lose credibility due to the astounding levels of hypocrisy from the right.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:45 pm
by old salt
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:39 pm
old salt wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:34 pm
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:33 am
Well, if we're done with the personal insults and emojis, it does seem to me that right wing media is doing its darnedest to paint the Biden Admin, specifically the State Dept as some sort of evil doers in the ongoing saga of getting Americans and allies out of Afghanistan.
First we have cradle's assertion, made by Fox and repeated by the NY Post, that Rick Clay (raising money for rescue efforts) and two unnamed private people say that the State Dept is slow walking specific approvals for individuals (vetting) and thus, some flights that might have happened, haven't.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... fghanistan
Might have some truth (if this was a GOP Admin anyone doubt that Fox and NYP would be claiming that the vetting was necessary???);...or is it because the Taliban are actually the ones holding up the planes from leaving? much more likely...
https://www.albawaba.com/news/why-doesn ... an-1445502
Then we have shortly within 24 hours of that story, another claiming that a rescue which the State Dept says they helped facilitate and is applauding, they are somehow claiming too much credit.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... -organizer
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
You do realize you are addressing 2 different rescue missions ?
In the overland rescue that succeeded, the group that organized, funded & facilitated the rescue is complaining that the State Dept is taking credit for the efforts of the volunteer group.
For the air recuse flights trapped in Mazir-I-Sharif, the State Dept is giving an evasive none answer. Of course we don't have anyone there to screen & verify the passengers & issue travel documents. This is an emergency air lift of evacuees from a war zone. The US State Dept has Embassy staff in Doha to coordinate these matters with the Qatari & Taliban officials there. Our SecState & SecDef are even there. All that should be reqd is for the US to assure the Qataris that all the passengers without the necessary documents will be immediately transported to the US. That should allow Qatar to issue diplomatic clearance for the flights to enter Qatar. All that's needed prior to departure is a thorough physical security check of the passengers & baggage. The US needs to assure that we will maintain custody of any passengers without the required travel documents & transport them to the US without extended delay for processing.
Of course I realize these are two different rescue efforts; the common denominator is Fox and others attacking the Biden Admin, specifically State dept. One for not doing enough (supposedly...or is that the Taliban are preventing departure), the other for taking credit for having a success happen.
There's going to be an incessant amount of these attacks on the Biden Admin. Some may actually be deserved, but they all lose credibility due to the astounding levels of hypocrisy from the right.
The Biden admin is also overstating (by implication) the number of evacuees by taking credit for the total numbers air lifted by the US, allies, NGO's, charters & commercial airlines. The USAF did not airlift all those souls out.
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 3:27 pm
by MDlaxfan76
old salt wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:45 pm
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:39 pm
old salt wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:34 pm
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:33 am
Well, if we're done with the personal insults and emojis, it does seem to me that right wing media is doing its darnedest to paint the Biden Admin, specifically the State Dept as some sort of evil doers in the ongoing saga of getting Americans and allies out of Afghanistan.
First we have cradle's assertion, made by Fox and repeated by the NY Post, that Rick Clay (raising money for rescue efforts) and two unnamed private people say that the State Dept is slow walking specific approvals for individuals (vetting) and thus, some flights that might have happened, haven't.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... fghanistan
Might have some truth (if this was a GOP Admin anyone doubt that Fox and NYP would be claiming that the vetting was necessary???);...or is it because the Taliban are actually the ones holding up the planes from leaving? much more likely...
https://www.albawaba.com/news/why-doesn ... an-1445502
Then we have shortly within 24 hours of that story, another claiming that a rescue which the State Dept says they helped facilitate and is applauding, they are somehow claiming too much credit.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... -organizer
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
You do realize you are addressing 2 different rescue missions ?
In the overland rescue that succeeded, the group that organized, funded & facilitated the rescue is complaining that the State Dept is taking credit for the efforts of the volunteer group.
For the air recuse flights trapped in Mazir-I-Sharif, the State Dept is giving an evasive none answer. Of course we don't have anyone there to screen & verify the passengers & issue travel documents. This is an emergency air lift of evacuees from a war zone. The US State Dept has Embassy staff in Doha to coordinate these matters with the Qatari & Taliban officials there. Our SecState & SecDef are even there. All that should be reqd is for the US to assure the Qataris that all the passengers without the necessary documents will be immediately transported to the US. That should allow Qatar to issue diplomatic clearance for the flights to enter Qatar. All that's needed prior to departure is a thorough physical security check of the passengers & baggage. The US needs to assure that we will maintain custody of any passengers without the required travel documents & transport them to the US without extended delay for processing.
Of course I realize these are two different rescue efforts; the common denominator is Fox and others attacking the Biden Admin, specifically State dept. One for not doing enough (supposedly...or is that the Taliban are preventing departure), the other for taking credit for having a success happen.
There's going to be an incessant amount of these attacks on the Biden Admin. Some may actually be deserved, but they all lose credibility due to the astounding levels of hypocrisy from the right.
The Biden admin is also overstating (by implication) the number of evacuees by taking credit for the total numbers air lifted by the US, allies, NGO's, charters & commercial airlines. The USAF did not airlift all those souls out.
sourpuss
These weren't exactly boat people escaping Vietnam and Cambodia.
This was an extraordinary achievement; thing is, probably could have been even better...certainly the public relations aspect could have been better, but I think there are some real questions about execution.
I don't buy that this was ohh so obvious an f-up, but I think that there's good reason to wonder whether this was really the best they could do, or did the military folks just not believe they were actually gonna have to leave, no more waffling and so miscalculated?
Certainly there were Americans who didn't heed the months of being told to get out...
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 3:44 pm
by cradleandshoot
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 3:27 pm
old salt wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:45 pm
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:39 pm
old salt wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:34 pm
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:33 am
Well, if we're done with the personal insults and emojis, it does seem to me that right wing media is doing its darnedest to paint the Biden Admin, specifically the State Dept as some sort of evil doers in the ongoing saga of getting Americans and allies out of Afghanistan.
First we have cradle's assertion, made by Fox and repeated by the NY Post, that Rick Clay (raising money for rescue efforts) and two unnamed private people say that the State Dept is slow walking specific approvals for individuals (vetting) and thus, some flights that might have happened, haven't.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... fghanistan
Might have some truth (if this was a GOP Admin anyone doubt that Fox and NYP would be claiming that the vetting was necessary???);...or is it because the Taliban are actually the ones holding up the planes from leaving? much more likely...
https://www.albawaba.com/news/why-doesn ... an-1445502
Then we have shortly within 24 hours of that story, another claiming that a rescue which the State Dept says they helped facilitate and is applauding, they are somehow claiming too much credit.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... -organizer
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
You do realize you are addressing 2 different rescue missions ?
In the overland rescue that succeeded, the group that organized, funded & facilitated the rescue is complaining that the State Dept is taking credit for the efforts of the volunteer group.
For the air recuse flights trapped in Mazir-I-Sharif, the State Dept is giving an evasive none answer. Of course we don't have anyone there to screen & verify the passengers & issue travel documents. This is an emergency air lift of evacuees from a war zone. The US State Dept has Embassy staff in Doha to coordinate these matters with the Qatari & Taliban officials there. Our SecState & SecDef are even there. All that should be reqd is for the US to assure the Qataris that all the passengers without the necessary documents will be immediately transported to the US. That should allow Qatar to issue diplomatic clearance for the flights to enter Qatar. All that's needed prior to departure is a thorough physical security check of the passengers & baggage. The US needs to assure that we will maintain custody of any passengers without the required travel documents & transport them to the US without extended delay for processing.
Of course I realize these are two different rescue efforts; the common denominator is Fox and others attacking the Biden Admin, specifically State dept. One for not doing enough (supposedly...or is that the Taliban are preventing departure), the other for taking credit for having a success happen.
There's going to be an incessant amount of these attacks on the Biden Admin. Some may actually be deserved, but they all lose credibility due to the astounding levels of hypocrisy from the right.
The Biden admin is also overstating (by implication) the number of evacuees by taking credit for the total numbers air lifted by the US, allies, NGO's, charters & commercial airlines. The USAF did not airlift all those souls out.
sourpuss
These weren't exactly boat people escaping Vietnam and Cambodia.
This was an extraordinary achievement; thing is, probably could have been even better...certainly the public relations aspect could have been better, but I think there are some real questions about execution.
I don't buy that this was ohh so obvious an f-up, but I think that there's good reason to wonder whether this was really the best they could do, or did the military folks just not believe they were actually gonna have to leave, no more waffling and so miscalculated?
Certainly there were Americans who didn't heed the months of being told to get out...
The last time I checked our military follows orders. They don't anticipate what the folks in DC will tell them to do. If you don't see this mess as the eff up it has been, you should get your spectacles checked. I'm sure when the dust settles and Biden has paid the Taliban the ransom they demand, the folks in DC can start having all the hearings to find out who was responsible for this cluster fudge. I'm certain there will be more than enough blame to go around. My first question I would like answered.. what dumb cluck, or group of dumb clucks were advising Joe? Did Joe pay any attention to the advice he was given? Did Joe just "go with his gut"?
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 3:58 pm
by runrussellrun
Farfromgeneva wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 11:25 am
You have no credibility here which is why they aren’t listening.
dried out my closet too
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 4:17 pm
by cradleandshoot
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 1:42 pm
Brooklyn wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 1:03 pm
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 12:35 pm
ISIS-K not Taliban
Brooklyn is correct about the astounding level of hypocrisy from the right.
But I object again and again to the tone, much less the label
traitor for the people desperate to make better Afghanistan
In their country their collaboration with the invading enemies who killed 100,000 of their countrymen it's called treason. If an invader entered the USA and collaborators helped them kill that many Americans, what would you call them? Just for the record, I would call them traitors and would happily attend their neck tie party at the scaffold.
So, too would our Founding Fathers have been hanged for "treason" had they been caught by the British. And we had French assistance.
Let's just say that we disagree strenuously.
I bet the British wish there was the internet and twitter way back in the early 1770s. They had to glean information the "old fashioned" way. That might have involved methods some folks on this forum might have found... shall we say... distasteful...
Re: Taliban reclaims Afghanistan
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2021 4:24 pm
by old salt
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 3:27 pm
old salt wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:45 pm
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:39 pm
old salt wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 2:34 pm
MDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 10:33 am
Well, if we're done with the personal insults and emojis, it does seem to me that right wing media is doing its darnedest to paint the Biden Admin, specifically the State Dept as some sort of evil doers in the ongoing saga of getting Americans and allies out of Afghanistan.
First we have cradle's assertion, made by Fox and repeated by the NY Post, that Rick Clay (raising money for rescue efforts) and two unnamed private people say that the State Dept is slow walking specific approvals for individuals (vetting) and thus, some flights that might have happened, haven't.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... fghanistan
Might have some truth (if this was a GOP Admin anyone doubt that Fox and NYP would be claiming that the vetting was necessary???);...or is it because the Taliban are actually the ones holding up the planes from leaving? much more likely...
https://www.albawaba.com/news/why-doesn ... an-1445502
Then we have shortly within 24 hours of that story, another claiming that a rescue which the State Dept says they helped facilitate and is applauding, they are somehow claiming too much credit.
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/state- ... -organizer
In other words, if you don't help enough or fast enough, or actually have to negotiate to do it safely, you're bums, and if you do help then noting that is taking undue credit, you're bums...pattern there?
You do realize you are addressing 2 different rescue missions ?
In the overland rescue that succeeded, the group that organized, funded & facilitated the rescue is complaining that the State Dept is taking credit for the efforts of the volunteer group.
For the air recuse flights trapped in Mazir-I-Sharif, the State Dept is giving an evasive none answer. Of course we don't have anyone there to screen & verify the passengers & issue travel documents. This is an emergency air lift of evacuees from a war zone. The US State Dept has Embassy staff in Doha to coordinate these matters with the Qatari & Taliban officials there. Our SecState & SecDef are even there. All that should be reqd is for the US to assure the Qataris that all the passengers without the necessary documents will be immediately transported to the US. That should allow Qatar to issue diplomatic clearance for the flights to enter Qatar. All that's needed prior to departure is a thorough physical security check of the passengers & baggage. The US needs to assure that we will maintain custody of any passengers without the required travel documents & transport them to the US without extended delay for processing.
Of course I realize these are two different rescue efforts; the common denominator is Fox and others attacking the Biden Admin, specifically State dept. One for not doing enough (supposedly...or is that the Taliban are preventing departure), the other for taking credit for having a success happen.
There's going to be an incessant amount of these attacks on the Biden Admin. Some may actually be deserved, but they all lose credibility due to the astounding levels of hypocrisy from the right.
The Biden admin is also overstating (by implication) the number of evacuees by taking credit for the total numbers air lifted by the US, allies, NGO's, charters & commercial airlines. The USAF did not airlift all those souls out.
sourpuss
These weren't exactly boat people escaping Vietnam and Cambodia.
This was an extraordinary achievement; thing is, probably could have been even better...certainly the public relations aspect could have been better, but I think there are some real questions about execution.
I don't buy that this was ohh so obvious an f-up, but I think that there's good reason to wonder whether this was really the best they could do, or did the military folks just not believe they were actually gonna have to leave, no more waffling and so miscalculated?
Certainly there were Americans who didn't heed the months of being told to get out...
Good grief ! It's more urgent than the SE Asian boat people. We have hundreds of Americans, loyal Afghan allies, & their families trapped behind enemy lines, & you're whining about Biden getting bad press & spinning a botched evacuation as an "extraordinary achievement".
Biden was assuring them that it was ok to stay, right up until the fall of Kabul, & encouraging Ghani to perpetuate the lie.
obtw -- re "boat people" I have friends (former shipmates & squadronmates) whose heroism helped save thousands of them. What a stupid analogy. Research the extraordinary efforts that Richard Armitage undertook to get them safely into the PI
https://www.npr.org/2010/09/01/12957826 ... nam-s-navy