get it to x wrote: ↑Mon Feb 27, 2023 4:17 pm
Seacoaster(1) wrote: ↑Mon Feb 27, 2023 1:27 pm
The war on public education is aimed at creating, exploiting and fund-raising off of cultural division. And the states are just the laboratories for "don't say gay," allegations of "grooming," elimination of uncomfortable history lessons, etc. And here, on a board supposedly devoted to lacrosse, we have posters who don't want their little flowers exposed to the historical trials of western expansion and the placing of Native Americans in camps. The campaign is "hate directed against anything that makes white culture uncomfortable.
If there is a war on public education, the educators/school boards fired the first shot. Parents being concerned with educators doing the following created the push back, which I would not call a war but a reassertion of parental rights::
- Telling kids the world will end in ten years because of climate change.
- Sexualizing kids before they have reached the age where they could understand. Not teaching physics to second graders, are they?
- The whole trans movement and telling little kids to question their gender. Then purposefully keeping it from parents.
- Racializing everything to the point where kids hate each other.
If you're an adult, anything you do sexually with another consenting adult is none of my business. Leave the kids out of it.
sigh...what are "parental rights"... in education?
On what basis are these "rights" derived?
Do you mean that
parents have a "right" to "indoctrinate" or otherwise treat their children however they wish, regardless of harm?
Is there no public interest when it comes to children?
I suspect we'd quite agree that "indoctrinating" children of a majority group to hate those of a minority group on the basis of their skin color, or that an adult's choice of sexual preference or gender identification is a sin and they will and should go to hell, or that violence against those we disagree or 'hate', and have relative power to, is appropriate in a democracy...or, we could go on and on...would be inappropriate whether coming from parent or school. Right?
So, too, we can imagine various converse scenarios that would be objectionable from the point of view of the public interest.
When I hear "parental rights" when applied to these sorts of topics, I hear generations of indoctrination that I'd bet most on here would find more than merely uncomfortable, they'd find it abhorrent. All in the supposed name of "parental control" or "parental rights".
The scenarios you paint above, get it to X, I'd argue are Not in the public interest...at least as you paint them.
But when does this "radicalizing" really happen when it comes to say, race in American history?
Who gets to say what is "radicalizing", the Neo-nazi parents?
What's actually "radical" about wanting to be sure that black and brown and white children learn that American history includes racist laws and practices impacting many generations of America, and that, nevertheless, Americans who were subject to these laws and practices persevered to help build a better and better America...is that "radical"??? Well, it sure as heck was when I was in elementary school. Indeed, it wasn't until 1967 when I was 10 that miscegenation laws were ruled unconstitutional...I remember discussing this with my parents and my father making a comment "birds of a feather flock together"...we had the same conversation just a few years later, maybe at age 14 or 15, and I told him how repugnant that logic was...he agreed. Times change, thank goodness.
I suspect we'll be looking back at issues like gay marriage (you know, 2 mommies or 2 daddies) in a few decades and wonder what all the fuss was about...unless you were part of a family just a few years ago going through the trauma of being denied such loving family commitments; something not guaranteed constitutionally until 2015 and not legislatively endorsed until 2022...last year!!
Is it "radical" for educators to want to be sure that children with same-sex parents are recognized as 'equal' in the eyes of their classmates?
Who gets to say, homophobic parents exercising their "parental rights"?
Likewise, I suspect we'll wonder what all the fuss was over gender identification...
But hey, just like the "Defense of Marriage Act" (which was ruled unconstitutional in 2013) needed to be rejected and replaced (last year by the Respect for Marriage Act), so too are bills claiming to be about "parental rights" to be informed by educators if their child has expressed an interest in a different pronoun being used by their teachers and classmates...even if the educator thinks the child may be in harm's way at home from such informing...