LaxPower Back-Up Stick

greenielax wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2019 1:33 pm Didn't see maddog's drops or post drop roster, but that doesn't affect my pick, so here we go.

Adam Charamblides A, rsjr Rutgers

He was not on the post-drop roster EZE posted. And just fyi, he was listed on the 2019 roster as a rs so, and is on the 2020 roster as a rs jr; the 2020 roster was posted as of last Monday when I was checking grad status's.

greenielax wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2019 1:33 pm Didn't see maddog's drops or post drop roster, but that doesn't affect my pick, so here we go.

Adam Charamblides A, rsjr Rutgers

He was not on the post-drop roster EZE posted. And just fyi, he was listed on the 2019 roster as a rs so, and is on the 2020 roster as a rs jr; the 2020 roster was posted as of last Monday when I was checking grad status's.

greenielax wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2019 4:06 pm First, the "getting the player back" situation was me. And two big reasons admin ruled the way he did were 1) it was an unforeseeable grad year situation, and 2) no one had noticed he was available and drafted him by the time I realized he was still on the roster.

I agree that admin gets to make the call, but I think this is a different situation because 1) the player's status was foreseeable if you would even have looked at the Rutgers roster last year (and in fact was discussed in the thread last year), i.e., this isn't a "gotcha" situation, 2) someone drafted him and 3) we have been repeatedly warned to check player status before drops.

EZE did not post his drops. He posted his post-drop keepers before he drafted (which several others have done, also).

greenielax wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2019 4:06 pm First, the "getting the player back" situation was me. And two big reasons admin ruled the way he did were 1) it was an unforeseeable grad year situation, and 2) no one had noticed he was available and drafted him by the time I realized he was still on the roster.

I agree that admin gets to make the call, but I think this is a different situation because 1) the player's status was foreseeable if you would even have looked at the Rutgers roster last year (and in fact was discussed in the thread last year), i.e., this isn't a "gotcha" situation, 2) someone drafted him and 3) we have been repeatedly warned to check player status before drops.

EZE did not post his drops. He posted his post-drop keepers before he drafted (which several others have done, also).

OCanada wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2019 4:55 pm I agree it needs to be fair. I also believe managers are responsible. If the draft had not started I would have no issue with returning the player. Once the draft begins though a different standard needs to be applied.

In our first round one player made a pick and then wanted to change it because he realized there was a much better player available. I assume Grey. He made a mistake. But had drafted.

I

OCanada wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2019 4:55 pm I agree it needs to be fair. I also believe managers are responsible. If the draft had not started I would have no issue with returning the player. Once the draft begins though a different standard needs to be applied.

In our first round one player made a pick and then wanted to change it because he realized there was a much better player available. I assume Grey. He made a mistake. But had drafted.

I