Tewaaraton Finalist

[Laxfanatic2022]

Who’s your 5?

This year it’s been pretty clear to me

Brennnan O’Neill
Pat Kavanagh
CJ Kirst
Gavin Adler
Connor Shellenberger - hard to be a finalist and not be your teams leading point scorer but still think he gets the nod

[laxerr20]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brennan Oneil

The winner should be CJ Kirst

[Finster]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

[Laxfanatic2022]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

I don’t see how you can put Brett Makar in over O’Neill. Makar started out hot and has slowed down entirely with some not so impressive games. Zappitello should be in there over him if you want to pick a Maryland defenseman. Also respect the Dickinson pick I don’t disagree with that, but he didn’t make the top 25 sadly

[10stone5]

I’ve got Adler and Kirst as the top two,
depends on where Cornell ends up,

Adler has been the most impressive player on the field so far.

[laxerr20]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

I don’t see how you can put Brett Makar in over O’Neill. Makar started out hot and has slowed down entirely with some not so impressive games. Zappitello should be in there over him if you want to pick a Maryland defenseman. Also respect the Dickinson pick I don’t disagree with that, but he didn’t make the top 25 sadly

I do not know how but I totally forgot about Oneil. I would have him in over Makar

[SkipPass]

Please stop with the Defenseman. It’s not going to happen. Makar and Zap are not the same caliber as Adler. Not even close.

[lorin]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

I don’t see how you can put Brett Makar in over O’Neill. Makar started out hot and has slowed down entirely with some not so impressive games. Zappitello should be in there over him if you want to pick a Maryland defenseman. Also respect the Dickinson pick I don’t disagree with that, but he didn’t make the top 25 sadly

I do not know how but I totally forgot about Oneil. I would have him in over Makar

Why would O’Neil be first please tell, because he was suppose to be or does he deserve based on his stats?

[Finster]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

I don’t see how you can put Brett Makar in over O’Neill. Makar started out hot and has slowed down entirely with some not so impressive games. Zappitello should be in there over him if you want to pick a Maryland defenseman. Also respect the Dickinson pick I don’t disagree with that, but he didn’t make the top 25 sadly

I do not know how but I totally forgot about Oneil. I would have him in over Makar

Why would O’Neil be first please tell, because he was suppose to be or does he deserve based on his stats?

71 points nicely distributed in goals and assists on the #1 team in the country.

In the biggest game of the year, the first UVA game: 9 points

In breaking their Syracuse Dome drought: 6 points.

He’s held up his end of the bargain.

Kirst SOG %: 61
Kirst SH%: 38

O’Neill SOG%: 64%
O’Neill SH%: 36%

[lorin]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

I don’t see how you can put Brett Makar in over O’Neill. Makar started out hot and has slowed down entirely with some not so impressive games. Zappitello should be in there over him if you want to pick a Maryland defenseman. Also respect the Dickinson pick I don’t disagree with that, but he didn’t make the top 25 sadly

I do not know how but I totally forgot about Oneil. I would have him in over Makar

Why would O’Neil be first please tell, because he was suppose to be or does he deserve based on his stats?

71 points nicely distributed in goals and assists on the #1 team in the country.

In the biggest game of the year, the first UVA game: 9 points

In breaking their Syracuse Dome drought: 6 points.

He’s held up his end of the bargain.

Kirst SOG %: 61
Kirst SH%: 38

O’Neill SOG%: 64%
O’Neill SH%: 36%

has of 4/26
GPG ranked 17th
APG ranked 16th
PPG ranked 9th

[Finster]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

I don’t see how you can put Brett Makar in over O’Neill. Makar started out hot and has slowed down entirely with some not so impressive games. Zappitello should be in there over him if you want to pick a Maryland defenseman. Also respect the Dickinson pick I don’t disagree with that, but he didn’t make the top 25 sadly

I do not know how but I totally forgot about Oneil. I would have him in over Makar

Why would O’Neil be first please tell, because he was suppose to be or does he deserve based on his stats?

71 points nicely distributed in goals and assists on the #1 team in the country.

In the biggest game of the year, the first UVA game: 9 points

In breaking their Syracuse Dome drought: 6 points.

He’s held up his end of the bargain.

Kirst SOG %: 61
Kirst SH%: 38

O’Neill SOG%: 64%
O’Neill SH%: 36%

has of 4/26
GPG ranked 17th
APG ranked 16th
PPG ranked 9th

That’s fair but you need to factor in the team rank as well as their SOS. He’s the best on the best.

[joewillie78]

If I was voting. My top 10 are:
1. Adler
2. Kirst
3. Dickson
4. O'Neil
5. Shellenberger
6. Kavanaugh
7. Zapitello
8. Mackasey
9. Melendez
10. Kurtz

I don't care if they were nominated or not. Those are my 10 best of the year......so far.

Gobigred
Joewillie78

[lorin]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

I don’t see how you can put Brett Makar in over O’Neill. Makar started out hot and has slowed down entirely with some not so impressive games. Zappitello should be in there over him if you want to pick a Maryland defenseman. Also respect the Dickinson pick I don’t disagree with that, but he didn’t make the top 25 sadly

I do not know how but I totally forgot about Oneil. I would have him in over Makar

Why would O’Neil be first please tell, because he was suppose to be or does he deserve based on his stats?

71 points nicely distributed in goals and assists on the #1 team in the country.

In the biggest game of the year, the first UVA game: 9 points

In breaking their Syracuse Dome drought: 6 points.

He’s held up his end of the bargain.

Kirst SOG %: 61
Kirst SH%: 38

O’Neill SOG%: 64%
O’Neill SH%: 36%

has of 4/26
GPG ranked 17th
APG ranked 16th
PPG ranked 9th

That’s fair but you need to factor in the team rank as well as their SOS. He’s the best on the best.

Kirst teams rank and SOS pretty good and he's 1 in GPG and Second in Points per game. he also is best of the best.

[joewillie78]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

I don’t see how you can put Brett Makar in over O’Neill. Makar started out hot and has slowed down entirely with some not so impressive games. Zappitello should be in there over him if you want to pick a Maryland defenseman. Also respect the Dickinson pick I don’t disagree with that, but he didn’t make the top 25 sadly

I do not know how but I totally forgot about Oneil. I would have him in over Makar

Why would O’Neil be first please tell, because he was suppose to be or does he deserve based on his stats?

71 points nicely distributed in goals and assists on the #1 team in the country.

In the biggest game of the year, the first UVA game: 9 points

In breaking their Syracuse Dome drought: 6 points.

He’s held up his end of the bargain.

Kirst SOG %: 61
Kirst SH%: 38

O’Neill SOG%: 64%
O’Neill SH%: 36%

has of 4/26
GPG ranked 17th
APG ranked 16th
PPG ranked 9th

That’s fair but you need to factor in the team rank as well as their SOS. He’s the best on the best.

Kirst teams rank and SOS pretty good and he's 1 in GPG and Second in Points per game. he also is best of the best.

Actually, I believe he is also FIRST in points per game as the player who was first was shutout this past Saturday by the player who is #1 on my list.
Gobigred
Joewillie78

[laxfan1313]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

I don’t see how you can put Brett Makar in over O’Neill. Makar started out hot and has slowed down entirely with some not so impressive games. Zappitello should be in there over him if you want to pick a Maryland defenseman. Also respect the Dickinson pick I don’t disagree with that, but he didn’t make the top 25 sadly

I do not know how but I totally forgot about Oneil. I would have him in over Makar

Why would O’Neil be first please tell, because he was suppose to be or does he deserve based on his stats?

71 points nicely distributed in goals and assists on the #1 team in the country.

In the biggest game of the year, the first UVA game: 9 points

In breaking their Syracuse Dome drought: 6 points.

He’s held up his end of the bargain.

Kirst SOG %: 61
Kirst SH%: 38

O’Neill SOG%: 64%
O’Neill SH%: 36%

has of 4/26
GPG ranked 17th
APG ranked 16th
PPG ranked 9th

That’s fair but you need to factor in the team rank as well as their SOS. He’s the best on the best.

Kirst teams rank and SOS pretty good and he's 1 in GPG and Second in Points per game. he also is best of the best.

Who is ahead of CJ in PPG? Right now, Mackesy has 45 goals and 20 assists for 65 points after 12 games after being shut out by Gavin Adler. That's 3.75 GPG and 5.417 PPG. CJ has 58 goals and 18 assists for 76 points after 13 games. That's 4.46 GPG and 5.846 PPG. I think CJ is #1 in both categories.

[joewillie78]

1313,
That's correct. Last I checked, they haven't updated the stats using this past weekends game, so lorin was I believe basing it on the non-updated stats.

Mackesey being shutout and Kirst getting 3,3 moved him well into 1st in both categories.

I'm sorry I had to vote him 2nd but ADLER, has been so dominant this year.

Actually, my vote if allowed should be:
1a. ADLER
1b. KIRST
Gobigred
Joewillie78

[Finster]

1313,
That's correct. Last I checked, they haven't updated the stats using this past weekends game, so lorin was I believe basing it on the non-updated stats.

Mackesey being shutout and Kirst getting 3,3 moved him well into 1st in both categories.

I'm sorry I had to vote him 2nd but ADLER, has been so dominant this year.

Actually, my vote if allowed should be:
1a. ADLER
1b. KIRST
Gobigred
Joewillie78

Not to get too deep into the weeds here, but there’s a freshman D on Lehigh who has 48 CT’s to Adler’s 20. More GB’s as well as points.

No way Adler wins the Tewey.

I can see Kirst getting it, but really, I think one of these guys, O’Neill, Kirst, or Shellenberger, will need to bring home the Ship to differentiate for the final vote.

[Finster]

If we are talking the five best players in college lacrosse THIS YEAR it should be
Pat Kav
Gavin Adler
CJ Kirst
Xander Dickson
Brett Makar

The winner should be CJ Kirst

Absolutely not to Kavanaugh. O’Neill and he should win. Otherwise your list is good.

I don’t see how you can put Brett Makar in over O’Neill. Makar started out hot and has slowed down entirely with some not so impressive games. Zappitello should be in there over him if you want to pick a Maryland defenseman. Also respect the Dickinson pick I don’t disagree with that, but he didn’t make the top 25 sadly

I do not know how but I totally forgot about Oneil. I would have him in over Makar

Why would O’Neil be first please tell, because he was suppose to be or does he deserve based on his stats?

71 points nicely distributed in goals and assists on the #1 team in the country.

In the biggest game of the year, the first UVA game: 9 points

In breaking their Syracuse Dome drought: 6 points.

He’s held up his end of the bargain.

Kirst SOG %: 61
Kirst SH%: 38

O’Neill SOG%: 64%
O’Neill SH%: 36%

has of 4/26
GPG ranked 17th
APG ranked 16th
PPG ranked 9th

That’s fair but you need to factor in the team rank as well as their SOS. He’s the best on the best.

Kirst teams rank and SOS pretty good and he's 1 in GPG and Second in Points per game. he also is best of the best.

Who is ahead of CJ in PPG? Right now, Mackesy has 45 goals and 20 assists for 65 points after 12 games after being shut out by Gavin Adler. That's 3.75 GPG and 5.417 PPG. CJ has 58 goals and 18 assists for 76 points after 13 games. That's 4.46 GPG and 5.846 PPG. I think CJ is #1 in both categories.

Sometimes a point leader is a combination of (obviously) being a great player, but also a reflection on the team simply not having many other weapons.

[10stone5]

That’s not the case with Cornell.

[Finster]

If I was voting. My top 10 are:
1. Adler
2. Kirst
3. Dickson
4. O'Neil
5. Shellenberger
6. Kavanaugh
7. Zapitello
8. Mackasey
9. Melendez
10. Kurtz

I don't care if they were nominated or not. Those are my 10 best of the year......so far.

Gobigred
Joewillie78

Did DocB pay you to include Melendez? What?!?!