UVA at Notre Dame Saturday 12 Noon

[a fan]

I think a few posters may have been incorrect about ND's superior D.

Fair. But the scoreboard prior to today suggested otherwise.

Also fair. But that's why they play the games. They'll have another chance against UVa in a few weeks.

[rcolter]

"Hockey background" must have led them to get chippy - give me a break

[keno in reno]

Carcaterra finished today with 1,357 sentences finished with "Right?" Nails on a chalkboard.

[wgdsr]

Cotter and Carc sound crestfallen that ND is going to lose

there has to be a radio feed. i have to do more due diligence.

[b1w7o9y7h]

Cotter and Carc sound crestfallen that ND is going to lose

No joke. They must have been hoping for an invite to Dickie V's Announcer's Camp this Summer.

[wgdsr]

Usually don't mind this duo that much but this commentary has been brutal

i don't know how u do it. they are brutal every time out. with the irish and the kavanaughs, it's just extra spice. right???

[jrn19]

Had the game on mute for the whole time only to return to the very inane "how would you rank the top 3??" conversation. was a mistake.

[MoralTerpitude]

Had the game on mute for the whole time only to return to the very inane "how would you rank the top 3??" conversation. was a mistake.

Some serious mental gymnastics to put both UVa and ND ahead of the Terps. I’m sure if the Terps played ND at this point in the season, they would win just as comfortably as UVa did.

That being said, par for the course with those clowns. And anyways with this Terps team, rankings are irrelevant.

[rolldodge]

Had the game on mute for the whole time only to return to the very inane "how would you rank the top 3??" conversation. was a mistake.

Some serious mental gymnastics to put both UVa and ND ahead of the Terps. I’m sure if the Terps played ND at this point in the season, they would win just as comfortably as UVa did.

That being said, par for the course with those clowns. And anyways with this Terps team, rankings are irrelevant.

Is it arguable? Sure. But mental gymnastics? No. You can make a reasonable argument for UVA and ND in front of Maryland.

[HopFan16]

When they're close and they all have a win over one of the others, think it makes sense to have somewhat of a recency bias when ranking them.

1. Virginia
2. Maryland
3. Notre Dame

[MoralTerpitude]

Had the game on mute for the whole time only to return to the very inane "how would you rank the top 3??" conversation. was a mistake.

Some serious mental gymnastics to put both UVa and ND ahead of the Terps. I’m sure if the Terps played ND at this point in the season, they would win just as comfortably as UVa did.

That being said, par for the course with those clowns. And anyways with this Terps team, rankings are irrelevant.

Is it arguable? Sure. But mental gymnastics? No. You can make a reasonable argument for UVA and ND in front of Maryland.

Maryland just beat UVa at their place. The justification was that Maryland lost to Loyola in early February. Anyone who has watched them at all in the last few weeks knows they are a completely different (and much better) team offensively.

And Carc is making the exact opposite argument that he used to justify ND getting into the tournament last year - that all games should or should not be considered equally.

So yeah… mental gymnastics.

[rolldodge]

Had the game on mute for the whole time only to return to the very inane "how would you rank the top 3??" conversation. was a mistake.

Some serious mental gymnastics to put both UVa and ND ahead of the Terps. I’m sure if the Terps played ND at this point in the season, they would win just as comfortably as UVa did.

That being said, par for the course with those clowns. And anyways with this Terps team, rankings are irrelevant.

Is it arguable? Sure. But mental gymnastics? No. You can make a reasonable argument for UVA and ND in front of Maryland.

Maryland just beat UVa at their place. The justification was that Maryland lost to Loyola in early February. Anyone who has watched them at all in the last few weeks knows they are a completely different (and much better) team offensively.

And Carc is making the exact opposite argument that he used to justify ND getting into the tournament last year - that all games should or should not be considered equally.

So yeah… mental gymnastics.

His particular logic may be convoluted, but you can make a logical argument based on body of work this season for UVA and Notre Dame over UMD. Marylands wins other than UVA are not that strong, plus they have two losses. Princeton-Yale result today helps them though.

[Gatsby]

Had the game on mute for the whole time only to return to the very inane "how would you rank the top 3??" conversation. was a mistake.

Some serious mental gymnastics to put both UVa and ND ahead of the Terps. I’m sure if the Terps played ND at this point in the season, they would win just as comfortably as UVa did.

That being said, par for the course with those clowns. And anyways with this Terps team, rankings are irrelevant.

Is it arguable? Sure. But mental gymnastics? No. You can make a reasonable argument for UVA and ND in front of Maryland.

Maryland just beat UVa at their place. The justification was that Maryland lost to Loyola in early February. Anyone who has watched them at all in the last few weeks knows they are a completely different (and much better) team offensively.

And Carc is making the exact opposite argument that he used to justify ND getting into the tournament last year - that all games should or should not be considered equally.

So yeah… mental gymnastics.

His particular logic may be convoluted, but you can make a logic argument based on body of work this season for UVA and Notre Dame over UMD. Marylands wins other than UVA are not that strong, plus they have two losses. Princeton-Yale result today helps them though.

I wouldn't even say it would require mental tai chi. These three teams all beat each other, with two games in overtime. One team also has an additional loss.

[jff97]

Have to give the defending national champions the benefit of the doubt, which means Notre Dame will remain at No. 1

[rolldodge]

Had the game on mute for the whole time only to return to the very inane "how would you rank the top 3??" conversation. was a mistake.

Some serious mental gymnastics to put both UVa and ND ahead of the Terps. I’m sure if the Terps played ND at this point in the season, they would win just as comfortably as UVa did.

That being said, par for the course with those clowns. And anyways with this Terps team, rankings are irrelevant.

Is it arguable? Sure. But mental gymnastics? No. You can make a reasonable argument for UVA and ND in front of Maryland.

Maryland just beat UVa at their place. The justification was that Maryland lost to Loyola in early February. Anyone who has watched them at all in the last few weeks knows they are a completely different (and much better) team offensively.

And Carc is making the exact opposite argument that he used to justify ND getting into the tournament last year - that all games should or should not be considered equally.

So yeah… mental gymnastics.

His particular logic may be convoluted, but you can make a logical argument based on body of work this season for UVA and Notre Dame over UMD. Marylands wins other than UVA are not that strong, plus they have two losses. Princeton-Yale result today helps them though.

A Maryland win over Penn State today would definitely make their case stronger. Lose though and it’s no longer arguable.

[Essexfenwick]

Carc says “Maryland beat uva with a spectacular goalie save”.. but makes no mention that technically, UMD beat ND in regulation since ND tying goal dove in the crease and landed well before the ball crossed the goal. He’s all biased against UMD omitting some facts and remembering other facts that fit his emotion. UMD led most of the game vs UVA and ND. That said … UVA and UMD have better coaches than ND and are therefore basically tied for 1st .

[MoralTerpitude]

Had the game on mute for the whole time only to return to the very inane "how would you rank the top 3??" conversation. was a mistake.

Some serious mental gymnastics to put both UVa and ND ahead of the Terps. I’m sure if the Terps played ND at this point in the season, they would win just as comfortably as UVa did.

That being said, par for the course with those clowns. And anyways with this Terps team, rankings are irrelevant.

Is it arguable? Sure. But mental gymnastics? No. You can make a reasonable argument for UVA and ND in front of Maryland.

Maryland just beat UVa at their place. The justification was that Maryland lost to Loyola in early February. Anyone who has watched them at all in the last few weeks knows they are a completely different (and much better) team offensively.

And Carc is making the exact opposite argument that he used to justify ND getting into the tournament last year - that all games should or should not be considered equally.

So yeah… mental gymnastics.

His particular logic may be convoluted, but you can make a logic argument based on body of work this season for UVA and Notre Dame over UMD. Marylands wins other than UVA are not that strong, plus they have two losses. Princeton-Yale result today helps them though.

I wouldn't even say it would require mental tai chi. These three teams all beat each other, with two games in overtime. One team also has an additional loss.

Let me state it another way. A reasonable person could certainly make a reasonable argument for UVa, ND, and the Terps as 1/2/3. Carc is not reasonable, and is clearly biased. He will use one set of logic for ND to make the tournament, then the exact opposite logic to rank them above the Terps.

Mental Tai Chi - love it.

[Essexfenwick]

Carc can’t forgive UMD 2022 arguably being the best lacrosse team ever and definitely the best team in the modern clock shot era. It drives him nuts.

[Comeonman]

Love this result.

[blue angels]

Had the game on mute for the whole time only to return to the very inane "how would you rank the top 3??" conversation. was a mistake.

Some serious mental gymnastics to put both UVa and ND ahead of the Terps. I’m sure if the Terps played ND at this point in the season, they would win just as comfortably as UVa did.

That being said, par for the course with those clowns. And anyways with this Terps team, rankings are irrelevant.

Is it arguable? Sure. But mental gymnastics? No. You can make a reasonable argument for UVA and ND in front of Maryland.

Maryland just beat UVa at their place. The justification was that Maryland lost to Loyola in early February. Anyone who has watched them at all in the last few weeks knows they are a completely different (and much better) team offensively.

And Carc is making the exact opposite argument that he used to justify ND getting into the tournament last year - that all games should or should not be considered equally.

So yeah… mental gymnastics.

I mean who cares who is 1,2 or3 right now? It will all change again as these teams move through conference play. Maryland is either 1, 2or 3 and a high likelihood to be there Memorial Day. Why worry about piddling stuff?