First, yes hating is bad. We need to discourage hating, regardless of by whom.ChairmanOfTheBoard wrote: ↑Mon Mar 18, 2019 8:50 pmMDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Mon Mar 18, 2019 4:26 pmYes, people can be 'bad' for their thoughts. They don't need to have become violent to have hateful bigotry in their hearts.ChairmanOfTheBoard wrote: ↑Mon Mar 18, 2019 1:14 pmMDlaxfan76 wrote: ↑Sun Mar 17, 2019 11:58 amI think this is literally true of white nationalists/white supremacists, although just like other perpetrators of evil, individuals within such a movement are capable of redemption. They aren't, however, "good people" until they actually reject such evil ideology.Typical Lax Dad wrote: ↑Sun Mar 17, 2019 11:51 amWhite nationalist are bad people. Just like extremist of all ilk.
Most never do.
what if it's merely a thought and no action?
can we call people "bad" for simply having thoughts?
alternatively, are black nationalists then bad people?
what about this one (a verbalized thought): "Israel has hypnotized the world, may Allah awaken the people and help them see the evil doings of Israel."
I can definitely speak to the ideology of white nationalism/white supremacy. Evil. Period. Horrendous legacy.
I don't think 'black nationalism' had the same notions of genetic superiority inherent in the white supremacy movement, but to the extent that hate was fostered, that's 'bad', evil.
On Omar's statement above, there's not necessarily an equivalence between "Israel" and Judaism or Jews. It's more complicated. What she meant though, may well have been anti-semitic, so I'm not letting her off the hook. But I'd give her a chance to redeem herself, and time to do so.
thanks- whether i agree or not- how to regulate?
and so we agree on the second point- if a person of color hates whites- they then are bad people.
that only leaves the question- do degrees matter here. i think no.
omar's statement can be as complicated as you want. israel is doing evil. doesnt matter what creed. it's hateful and that makes her bad, by your logic. full stop nope.
But anger is not necessarily 'hate', and degree does matter.
Nor should we assume that people are "bad" as in irredeemable. Haters, racist or otherwise, can change.
Unfortunately, it's hard to get that to happen. Requires a true awakening.
"regulate" is another thing. There, yes, "degree" very much does "matter".
We need to be careful about what speech, what beliefs, are 'regulated'. If it's calling for violence, fomenting hate for the purpose of triggering violence, we need to find ways to get that closed down. The white supremacist machine is quite akin to the ISIS propaganda machine. Very dangerous.
On your statement about Omar, I don't follow your logic. Thinking that Netanyahu's gov't's policies towards settlements and Palestinians etc are 'evil' and 'hating' those policies is perfectly legitimate IMO.
Jumping from that to hating Jews and Judaism, claiming that Jews control the world monetarily and against God's law, that Jews are leading a global cabal to encourage "invaders" to "mongrelize" the white race, that "the Jews killed Christ", this is very dangerous rhetoric with an enormous, proven history of great evil by such groups.
Omar needs to get very clear about this stuff, and be very careful about not falling into tropes used by such hate groups. Else she needs to be benched.