| First Team |
| A-Sam Apuzzo, Boston College, Jr. |
| A-Kristen Gaudian, James Madison, Sr. |
| A-Courtney Murphy, Stony Brook, R-Sr. |
| A-Kylie Ohlmiller, Stony Brook, Sr. |
| A-Megan Whittle, Maryland, Sr. |
| A/Draw-Olivia Jenner, Duke, Jr. |
| M-Dempsey Arsenault, Boston College, Jr. |
| M-Jenna Collins, Navy, Sr. |
| M-Marie McCool, North Carolina, Sr. |
| D-Julia Braig, Maryland, Jr. |
| D-Brooke Gubitosi, Stony Brook, R-Sr. |
| D-Elizabeth Miller, Boston College, Jr. |
| D-Cara Trombetta, Florida, So. |
| G-Julia Lisella, Colorado, So. |
| *An additional All-America attack selection has been added to the First Team due to a tie in voting. |
| Second Team |
| A-Katie Hoeg, North Carolina, So. |
| A-Kelly Larkin, Navy, So. |
| A-Selena Lasota, Northwestern, Jr. |
| A-Taryn Ohlmiller, Stony Brook, So. |
| A/Draw-Darby Kiernan, Colorado, Sr. |
| M-Sheila Nesselbush, Northwestern, Sr. |
| M-Katie O’Donnell, Penn State, Sr. |
| M-Haley Warden, James Madison, Sr. |
| D-Lizzie Colson, Maryland, So. |
| D-Olivia Conti, Towson, So. |
| D-Natalie Stefan, Penn, Sr. |
| D-Kristen Yanchoris, Loyola, Jr. |
| G-Haley Hicklen, Florida, Jr. |
| Third Team |
| A-Zoe Belodeau, Penn, Fr. |
| A-Ela Hazar, North Carolina, Sr. |
| A-Jamie Ortega, North Carolina, Fr. |
| A-Lindsey Ronbeck, Florida, Jr. |
| A-Livy Rosenzweig, Loyola, Fr. |
| A/Draw-Shelby Fredericks, Northwestern, Sr. |
| M-Kerrigan Miller, USC, So. |
| M-Elena Romesburg, James Madison, Sr. |
| M-Taylor VanThof, Loyola, Jr. |
| D-Sarah Brown, Colorado, Sr. |
| D-Sabrina Cristodero, Florida, Fr. |
| D-Hannah Hyatt, Boston College, Jr. |
| D-Lydia Sutton, USC, Sr. |
| G-Anna Tesoriero, Stony Brook, Jr. |
| *An additional All-America attack selection has been added to the Third Team due to a tie in voting. |
| Honorable Mention |
| A-Julia Collins, Navy, Sr. |
| A-Julia Glynn, Harvard, Sr. |
| A-Kaileen Hart, Boston College, Sr. |
| A-Kelsey Murray, Stanford, R-Sr. |
| A-Charlotte North, Duke, Fr. |
| A-Shayna Pirreca, Florida, Sr. |
| A-Gabby Rosenzweig, Penn, So. |
| A-Kyla Sears, Princeton, Fr. |
| A-Caroline Steele, Maryland, Jr. |
| A/Draw-Madison Carter, Penn State, Jr. |
| M/Draw-Kathryn Giroux, Dartmouth, Jr. |
| A/Draw-Kali Hartshorn, Maryland, So. |
| A-Draw-Izzy Nixon, Yale, Jr. |
| M-Kasey Behr, Virginia, Sr. |
| M-Jen Giles, Maryland, Jr. |
| M-Maggie Jackson, Virginia, Jr. |
| M-Ally Kennedy, Stony Brook, So. |
| M-Erica Perrotta, High Point, Sr. |
| M-Paige Petty, Virginia Tech, Fr. |
| M-Sydney Pirreca, Florida, Jr. |
| D-Carly Bell, Boston College, Sr. |
| D-Kayla Brisolari, Penn State, Jr. |
| D-Sami Chenoweth, Towson, So. |
| D-Kerry Defliese, Syracuse, So. |
| D-Kelly Glatthorn, Virginia Tech, Sr. |
| D-Katy Junior, Penn, Jr. |
| D-Erin Kelly, North Carolina, So. |
| D-Julia Massaro, Stanford, Jr. |
| D-Blake Smith, Navy, Sr. |
| D-Rebecca Tooker, James Madison, Sr. |
| D-Tianna Wallpher, Towson, Sr. |
| G-Sam Fish, Princeton, Fr. |
| G-Taylor Moreno, North Carolina, R-Fr. |
| G-Megan Taylor, Maryland, Jr. |
