First Team
| Dakota | Adamec | Tufts University | Junior | Attack |
| Kyra | Bednarski | Stevens Institute of Technology | Sophomore | Attack |
| Miranda | Chrone | The College of New Jersey | Junior | Goalkeeper |
| Nicole | Clauter | York College of PA | Junior | Defense |
| Kiley | Coffey | Trinity College | Senior | Attack |
| Steph | Colson | Gettysburg College | Junior | Midfield |
| Hailey | Dobbins | SUNY Cortland | Junior | Defense |
| Zoe | Ferguson | Trinity College | Senior | Goalkeeper |
| Meghan | Fox | York College of PA | Sophomore | Attack |
| Allie | Hynson | Salisbury University | Senior | Midfield |
| Evie | Keating | Middlebury College | Senior | Defense |
| Kirsten | Littlefield | University of Mary Washington | Senior | Defense |
| Emma | McDonagh | Middlebury College | Junior | Attack |
| Lexie | Meager | SUNY Cortland | Sophomore | Midfield |
| Paige | Moriarty | Franklin and Marshall College | Senior | Attack |
| Elizabeth | Morrison | The College of New Jersey | Senior | Defense |
| Krissy | Murphy | Salisbury University | Senior | Attack |
| Hollis | Perticone | Middlebury College | Senior | Midfield |
| Sabrina | Solow | Amherst College | Junior | Defense |
Second Team
| Allie | Barrett | Trinity College | Senior | Midfield |
| Olivia | Cleale | The College of New Jersey | Sophomore | Attack |
| Julia | Crerend | Amherst College | Senior | Attack |
| Erin | Dugan | Catholic University of America | Junior | Defense |
| Gianna | Falcone | Salisbury University | Senior | Goalkeeper |
| Maggie | Hanzsche | Franklin and Marshall College | Sophomore | Defense |
| Kendra | Herbenar | Messiah College | Senior | Defense |
| Hannah | Hirschfeld | Bowdoin College | Senior | Attack |
| Abby | Horst | Wesleyan University | Junior | Midfield |
| Kathleen | Jaeger | The College of New Jersey | Junior | Midfield |
| Steph | Kelly | Colorado College | Senior | Attack |
| Molly | Long | Ithaca College | Senior | Defense |
| Mackenzie | Maguire | University of Mary Washington | Junior | Attack |
| Melissa | Moore | William Smith College | Senior | Midfield |
| Evan | Murphy | Claremont Mudd Scripps Colleges | Senior | Midfield |
| Maia | Noyes | Amherst College | Freshman | Midfield |
| Allie | Panara | Ithaca College | Junior | Attack |
| Caroline | Sgaglione | Wesleyan University | Junior | Defense |
| Courtney | Wagner | Messiah College | Junior | Attack |
Third Team
| Maddie | Bray | Rowan University | Junior | Attack |
| Jackie | Brokaw | Colby College | Senior | Defense |
| Georgia | Carroll | Middlebury College | Senior | Attack |
| Jess | Castelo | Washington & Lee University | Senior | Attack |
| Kendall | Cunningham | Rhodes College | Senior | Attack |
| Eliza | Denious | Bowdoin College | Freshman | Midfield |
| Jane | Goodspeed | Denison University | Junior | Defense |
| Taylor | Gretz | Rowan University | Junior | Midfield |
| Danielle | Harrington | Franklin and Marshall College | Senior | Goalkeeper |
| Holly | Hite | Meredith College | Junior | Midfield |
| Devin | Hursey | York College of PA | Sophomore | Midfield |
| Martha | Hutzell | Salisbury University | Junior | Defense |
| Leah | Israel | Denison University | Senior | Midfield |
| Katie | Landry | Gettysburg College | Senior | Attack |
| Mekayla | Montgomery | William Smith College | Sophomore | Defense |
| Madison | Schutz | Washington College | Junior | Defense |
| Teresa | Shattuck | Oswego State | Junior | Attack |
| Annie | Sullivan | Tufts University | Junior | Midfield |
| Hedy | Veith | Tufts University | Junior | Defense |
