| First Team |
| Attack: Molly Hendrick, North Carolina, Sr. |
| Attack: Olivia Hompe, Princeton, Sr. |
| Attack: Michaela Michael, USC, Sr. |
| Attack: Kylie Ohlmiller, Stony Brook, Jr. |
| Draw Specialist: Sammy Jo Tracy, North Carolina, Sr. |
| Midfield: Sarah Martin, Albany, Sr. |
| Midfield: Marie McCool, North Carolina, Jr. |
| Midfield: Zoe Stukenberg, Maryland, Sr. |
| Defense: Caroline Fitzgerald, Florida, Sr. |
| Defense: Brooke Gubitosi, Stony Brook, R-Jr. |
| Defense: Nadine Hadnagy, Maryland, Sr. |
| Defense: Lydia Sutton, USC, Jr. |
| Goalie: Ellie DeGarmo, Princeton, Sr. |
| Second Team |
| Attack: Sam Apuzzo, Boston College, So. |
| Attack: Steph Lazo, Penn State, Sr. |
| Attack: Mollie Stevens, Florida, Sr. |
| Attack: Megan Whittle, Maryland, Jr. |
| Draw Specialist: Hannah Murphy, UMass, Sr. |
| Midfield: Jenna Collins, Navy, Jr. |
| Midfield: Alex Condon, Penn, Jr. |
| Midfield: Haley Warden, James Madison, Jr. |
| Defense: Taylor Bresnahan, Florida, Sr. |
| Defense: Olivia Conti, Towson, Fr. |
| Defense: Claire Quinn, Northwestern, So. |
| Defense: Catie Smith, Cornell, Sr. |
| Goalie: Megan Taylor, Maryland, So. |
| Third Team |
| Attack: Sammi Burgess, Florida, Sr. |
| Attack: Madison Carter, Penn State, So. |
| Attack: Cortney Fortunato, Notre Dame, Sr. |
| Attack: Kenzie Kent, Boston College, Jr. |
| Draw Specialist: Shelby Fredericks, Northwestern, Jr. |
| Midfield: Erica Evans, Canisius, Jr. |
| Midfield: Katie O’Donnell, Penn State, Jr. |
| Midfield: Casey Pearsall, Notre Dame, Sr. |
| Defense: Dempsey Arsenault, Boston College, So. |
| Defense: Maggie Auslander, North Carolina, Sr. |
| Defense: Sarah Crowley, UMass, Sr. |
| Defense: Katy Junior, Penn, So. |
| Goalie: Paige Soenksen, Colorado, Sr. |
