| Brennan O’Neill | A | St. Anthony’s (N.Y.) | 2020 | Duke |
| Owen Murphy | A | Avon Old Farms (Conn.) | 2019 | Johns Hopkins |
| Cole Kirst | A | Seton Hall Prep (N.J.) | 2018 | Lehigh |
| Daniel Kelly | A | Calvert Hall (Md.) | 2020 | North Carolina |
| Lance Tillman | A | Valor Christian (Colo.) | 2019 | North Carolina |
| Patrick Kavanagh | A | Taft School (Conn.) | 2019 | Notre Dame |
| Alex Slusher | A | Oregon Episcopal School (Ore.) | 2019 | Princeton |
| Connor Drake | M | Salisbury School (Conn.) | 2019 | Duke |
| Jake Caputo | M | Middle Creek (N.C.) | 2019 | Duke |
| Graham Bundy Jr. | M | MICS (Mo.) | 2019 | Georgetown |
| Brendan Grimes | M | Boys’ Latin (Md.) | 2020 | Johns Hopkins |
| Cole Herbert | M | Calvert Hall (Md.) | 2020 | North Carolina |
| Emmett Barger | M | St. Anne’s Belfield (Va.) | 2019 | Notre Dame |
| Connor Mitchell | M | Calvert Hall (Md.) | 2019 | Ohio State |
| Grant Mitchell | M | Calvert Hall (Md.) | 2019 | Ohio State |
| Jack Monfort | M | Syosset (N.Y.) | 2019 | Yale |
| Patrick Hackler | M | Skaneateles (N.Y.) | 2019 | Yale |
| Alec Stathakis | FO | Culver Military (Ind.) | 2019 | Denver |
| Connor Calderone | FO | Smithtown West (N.Y.) | 2019 | Maryland |
| Jake Naso | FO | St. Anthony’s (N.Y.) | 2020 | Virginia |
| Cole Krauss | D | Delbarton (N.J.) | 2020 | Duke |
| Gregory Campisi | D | St. Anthony’s (N.Y.) | 2019 | Harvard |
| Ryan Schriber | D | Wilton (Conn.) | 2019 | Michigan |
| Jackson Bonitz | D | McDonogh (Md.) | 2020 | Navy |
| Jacob Snyder | D | Calvert Hall (Md.) | 2019 | Ohio State |
| Edward Sutton Boland | D | Victor (N.Y.) | 2019 | Penn State |
| Quentin Matsui | D | Eden Prairie (Minn.) | 2019 | Virginia |
| BJ Burlace | D | St. Mary’s (Md.) | 2019 | Yale |
| Michael Alexander | D | West Islip (N.Y.) | 2019 | Yale |
| Liam Entenmann | G | Chaminade (N.Y.) | 2019 | Notre Dame |
| Christian Tomei | G | Oxbridge Academy (Fla.) | 2019 | Ohio State |
| Jared Paquette | G | West Islip (N.Y.) | 2019 | Yale |
