2018
| Catholic (CHSAA) | Joe Persico | 2018 | Goalie | Iona Preparatory |
| Catholic (CHSAA) | Thomas Marra | 2018 | Attack | Fordham Preparatory |
| NYSAIS (Independent) | Robert Hite | 2018 | Attack | Hackley School |
| NYSAIS (Independent) | Patrick O’Hagan | 2018 | Attack | Ethical Culture Fieldston School |
| PSAL (NYC Public) | Thomas Casuccio | 2018 | Goalie | Tottenville |
| PSAL (NYC Public) | Clifford Pollard | 2018 | Attack | Fredrick Douglas |
| PSAL (NYC Public) | Mamadou Meite | 2018 | Midfield | Fredrick Douglas |
| PSAL (NYC Public) | Jack Eschman | 2018 | Attack | Hunter College |
| Section 2 (Albany) | Sam Swingruber | 2018 | Midfield | Ballston Spa |
| Section 2 (Albany) | Griffin king | 2019 | Midfield | Niskayuna |
| Section 2 (Albany) | Luke Julian | 2018 | Attack | Shaker |
| Section 2 (Albany) | Eoghan Sweeney | 2018 | Midfield | Niskayuna |
| Section 2 (Albany) | Luke McMahon | 2018 | LSM | Christian Brothers Academy |
| Section 3 (Central) | Griffin Cook | 2018 | Attack | Jamesville-Dewitt |
| Section 3 (Central) | Peter Fiorini III | 2018 | Midfield | Charles W Baker |
| Section 3 (Central) | Jake Morin | 2018 | Midfield | Auburn High School |
| Section 3 (Central) | Tom Baker | 2018 | Defense | West Genesee |
| Section 3 (Central) | Dante Yacavone | 2018 | Attack | Homer High School |
| Section 3 (Central) | Vincent Basile | 2018 | Attack | Homer High School |
| Section 4 (Southern Tier) | Nick Conklin | 2018 | Defense | Johnson City |
| Section 4 (Southern Tier) | James Morris | 2018 | Defense | Vestal |
| Section 4 (Southern Tier) | Ryan Sposito | 2018 | Midfield | Ithaca |
| Section 5 (Rochester/Fingerlakes) | Trevor Ford | 2018 | Attack | Webster Thomas |
| Section 5 (Rochester/Fingerlakes) | Chayse Ierlan | 2018 | Goalie | Victor |
| Section 5 (Rochester/Fingerlakes) | Alexander Mabbett | 2018 | Midfield | Victor |
| Section 5 (Rochester/Fingerlakes) | Reese Burek | 2018 | Attack | Fairport |
| Section 5 (Rochester/Fingerlakes) | Alexander Mabbett | 2018 | Attack | Victor |
| Section 5 (Rochester/Fingerlakes) | Brady McDermott | 2018 | Midfield | Brighton |
| Section 5 (Rochester/Fingerlakes) | Garrett Ruff | 2018 | Midfield | Honeoye Falls |
| Section 6 (Western) | Owen Hill | 2018 | Midfield | Akron |
| Section 6 (Western) | Ben Mazur | 2018 | Goalie | Lancaster |
| Section 6 (Western) | Brett Beetow | 2018 | Midfield | Lancaster |
| Section 6 (Western) | Tom Cecere | 2018 | Attack | Grand Island |
| Section 6 (Western) | Zack Belter | 2018 | Defense | Niagara Wheatfield |
| Section 6 (Western) | Christian Watts | 2018 | Midfield | Timon |
| Section 8 (Nassau County) | Edward Arnold | 2020 | Defense | Manhasset |
| Section 8 (Nassau County) | Colin Hart | 2019 | Defense | Garden City |
| Section 8 (Nassau County) | Tim Hegarty | 2018 | Defense | Farmingdale |
| Section 8 (Nassau County) | Nick LiCalzi | 2020 | LSM | South Side |
| Section 8 (Nassau County) | Danny Ochs | 2018 | Defense | Syosset |
| Section 8 (Nassau County) | Angelo Petrakis | 2019 | Midfield | Massapequa |
| Section 8 (Nassau County) | Alex Vardaro | 2018 | Midfield | Hewlett |
| Section 8 (Nassau County) | Max Verch | 2018 | LSM | Syosset |
| Section 8 (Nassau County) | Kevin Winkoff | 2018 | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor |
| Section 9 (Mid-Hudson) | Hudson Miller | 2018 | Midfield | Red Hook |
| Section 9 (Mid-Hudson) | Jack Young | 2019 | Defense | Highland |
| Section 9 (Mid-Hudson) | Danny Fitzpatrick | 2018 | Attack | Monroe Woodbury |
| Section 9 (Mid-Hudson) | Jarek Rawl | 2018 | Midfield | Rondout Valley |
| Section 11 (Suffolk County) | George Wichelns | 2018 | Attack | Connetquot |
| Section 11 (Suffolk County) | Conor Calderone | 2019 | Midfield | Smithtown West |
| Section 11 (Suffolk County) | John Sidorski | 2019 | Attack | East Islip |
| Section 11 (Suffolk County) | Peter LaSalla | 2018 | Midfield | Rocky Point |
| Section 11 (Suffolk County) | Zach Hobbes | 2018 | Midfield | Ward Melville |
| Section 11 (Suffolk County) | Bobby Abshire | 2018 | Midfield | Commack |
| Section 11 (Suffolk County) | Ethan Rall | 2018 | LSM | Islip |
| Section 11 (Suffolk County) | Kyle Zawadzki | 2018 | Attack | Smithtown West |
