| YEAR | CHAMPION | SCORE | RUNNER-UP | HOST OR SITE |
| 2018 | Merrimack | 23-6 | Saint Leo | Foxborough, Mass. |
| 2017 | Limestone (21-1) | 11-9 | Merrimack | Foxborough, Mass. |
| 2016 | Le Moyne (20-0) | 8-4 | Limestone | Philadelphia |
| 2015 | Limestone (20-1) | 9-6 | Le Moyne | Philadelphia |
| 2014 | Limestone (19-1) | 12-6 | LIU Post | Baltimore |
| 2013 | Le Moyne (18-2) | 11-10 | Mercyhurst | Philadelphia |
| 2012 | Dowling (13-2) | 11-10 | Limestone | Foxborough, Mass. |
| 2011 | Mercyhurst (14-2) | 9-8 | Adelphi | Baltimore |
| 2010 | C.W. Post (16-1) | 14–9 | Le Moyne | Baltimore |
| 2009 | C.W. Post (15-1) | 8-7 | Le Moyne | Boston |
| 2008 | NYIT (13-1) | 16-11 | Le Moyne | Boston |
| 2007 | Le Moyne (15-2) | 6-5 | Mercyhurst | Baltimore |
| 2006 | Le Moyne (18-0) | 12-5 | Dowling | Philadelphia |
| 2005 | NYIT (10-2) | 14-13 (ot) | Limestone | Philadelphia |
| 2004 | Le Moyne (16-0) | 11-10 (2ot) | Limestone | Baltimore |
| 2003 | NYIT (14-0) | 9-4 | Limestone | Baltimore |
| 2002 | Limestone (13-2) | 11-9 | NYIT | Rutgers |
| 2001 | Adelphi (12-2) | 14-10 | Limestone | Rutgers |
| 2000 | Limestone (14-2) | 10-9 | C.W. Post | Maryland |
| 1999 | Adelphi (10-3) | 11-8 | C.W. Post | Maryland |
| 1998 | Adelphi (12-3) | 18-6 | C.W. Post | Rutgers |
| 1997 | NYIT (12-2) | 18-11 | Adelphi | Adelphi |
| 1996 | C.W. Post (10-3) | 15-10 | Adelphi | C.W. Post |
| 1995 | Adelphi (10-3) | 12-10 | Springfield | Springfield |
| 1994 | Springfield (12-2) | 15-12 | NYIT | C.W. Post |
| 1993 | Adelphi (8-3) | 11-7 | C.W. Post | C.W. Post |
| 1981 | Adelphi (10-2) | 17-14 | Loyola Maryland | Adelphi |
| 1980 | UMBC (11-3) | 23-14 | Adelphi | UMBC |
| 1979 | Adelphi (13-3) | 17-12 | UMBC | Adelphi |
| 1978 | Roanake (12-2) | 14-13 | Hobart | Hobart |
| 1977 | Hobart (15-0) | 23-13 | Washington College | Hobart |
| 1976 | Hobart (14-3) | 18-9 | Adelphi | UMBC |
| 1975 | SUNY Cortland (10-4) | 12-11 | Hobart | C.W. Post |
| 1974 | Towson (14-1) | 18-17 (ot) | Hobart | SUNY Cortland |
