| Position | Team | First | Last | School |
| Attack | 1st | Kyle | Killen | RIT |
| Attack | 1st | Thomas | Pfeiffer | York College of PA |
| Attack | 1st | A.J. | Witherell | Washington & Lee |
| Attack | 1st | Evan | Wolf | Amherst |
| Midfield | 1st | Shawn | Nally | RIT |
| Midfield | 1st | Nick | Shanks | Tufts |
| Midfield | 1st | IV | Stucker | Roanoke |
| Midfield | 1st | Matt | Whitcher | York College of PA |
| Defense | 1st | Joey | Fiorino | York College of PA |
| Defense | 1st | Alex | Maruna | RIT |
| Defense | 1st | Will | Nowesnick | Salisbury |
| Defense | 1st | Kyle | Tucker | Salisbury |
| SSDM | 1st | Peter | Hamblett | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| LSM | 1st | Eli | Salama | RIT |
| Faceoff | 1st | Nate | Farrell | RIT |
| Goalie | 1st | Ian | Davies | Roanoke |
| Position | Team | First | Last | School |
| Attack | 2nd | Jordan | Krug | Cabrini University |
| Attack | 2nd | Dylan | Maher | Dickinson College |
| Attack | 2nd | Danny | Murphy | Tufts |
| Attack | 2nd | Peter | Pittroff | Denison |
| Midfield | 2nd | Matt | Crowell | Bowdoin College |
| Midfield | 2nd | Corey | Gwin | Salisbury |
| Midfield | 2nd | Dillon | Hannah | York College of PA |
| Midfield | 2nd | Jack | Harvey | Gettysburg |
| Attack | 2nd | Kevin | Mollihan | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Defense | 2nd | Conn | Curry | Roanoke |
| Defense | 2nd | Ben | Duhoski | Denison |
| Defense | 2nd | Eric | Rogers | Middlebury College |
| Defense | 2nd | Mitch | Wykoff | Gettysburg College |
| SSDM | 2nd | Troy | Miller | Salisbury |
| LSM | 2nd | Nate | Usich | Dickinson College |
| Faceoff | 2nd | Dylan | Finazzo | Amherst |
| Goalie | 2nd | Walker | Hare | RIT |
| Position | Team | First | Last | School |
| Attack | 3rd | Maxwell | Bailey | Stevens |
| Attack | 3rd | Carter | Hawthorne | Wesleyan |
| Attack | 3rd | Colin | Minicus | Amherst |
| Attack | 3rd | Harry | Stanton | Wesleyan |
| Midfield | 3rd | Christian | Barker | Wesleyan |
| Midfield | 3rd | Luke | Leyden | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Midfield | 3rd | Michael | McCormack | Middlebury College |
| Midfield | 3rd | Matt | Solberg | Amherst |
| Defense | 3rd | J.D. | Beck | York College of PA |
| Defense | 3rd | Sam | Boehle | St. Lawrence University |
| Defense | 3rd | Connor | Lansdale | Tufts |
| Defense | 3rd | Parker | Sessions | Bowdoin College |
| Defense | 3rd | Winston | Wenham | Ithaca |
| SSDM | 3rd | Jimmy | McAfee | Amherst |
| LSM | 3rd | Jordan | Sanford | Amherst |
| Faceoff | 3rd | Ryan | Campbell | Dickinson College |
| Goalie | 3rd | Cole | Pellicano | Dickinson College |
| Position | Team | First | Last | School |
| Attack | HM | Tim | Brooks | Cabrini University |
| Attack | HM | Conor | Caffrey | St. Lawrence University |
| Attack | HM | Matt | Chlastawa | Bates College |
| Attack | HM | Ethan | Christensen | Stevenson University |
| Attack | HM | Ben | Connelly | Tufts |
| Attack | HM | Matthew | Crist | Christopher Newport |
| Attack | HM | Terrence | Haggerty | Cortland |
| Attack | HM | Tommy | Heller | Gettysburg College |
| Attack | HM | Steven | Hildebrand | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Attack | HM | Ryan | Hubbard | Plattsburgh State |
| Attack | HM | Clarke | Jones | Bates College |
| Attack | HM | Luke | Keating | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Attack | HM | Brian | Kolen | Gettysburg College |
| Attack | HM | Ian | Levin | Hampden-Sydney College |
| Attack | HM | Evan | Lombardo | Lynchburg |
| Attack | HM | Matt | LoParo | Cabrini University |
| Attack | HM | Zach | Lukas | RPI |
| Attack | HM | Jake | Lynch | Alfred University |
| Attack | HM | Devin | Phelps | Cortland |
| Attack | HM | Henry | Riehl | Middlebury College |
| Attack | HM | Sean | Rogers | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Attack | HM | Andrew | Rosso | St. John Fisher College |
| Attack | HM | Jason | Sarro | Roanoke |
| Attack | HM | Robbie | Stern | Colorado College |
| Attack | HM | Maxwell | Tennant | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Attack | HM | JT | Thelen | Stevenson University |
| Attack | HM | Nick | Treon | U.S. Merchant Marine Academy |
| Midfield | HM | Lucas | Bastarache | RPI |
| Midfield | HM | John | Boutureira | Stevens |
| Midfield | HM | Bennett | Bradley | Catholic |
| Midfield | HM | George | Briggs | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Midfield | HM | Hunter | Brown | Hampden-Sydney College |
| Midfield | HM | Conner | Crosson | Ithaca |
| Midfield | HM | Tommy | Dawson | Stevens |
| Midfield | HM | Josh | Della Puca | Ithaca |
| Midfield | HM | Harrison | Faetcher | Stevenson University |
| Midfield | HM | Tommy | Gallo | Stockton University |
| Midfield | HM | Nick | Gamba | Western New England |
| Midfield | HM | Andrew | Garstka | Gettysburg College |
| Midfield | HM | Taylor | Ghesquiere | Wesleyan |
| Midfield | HM | Adam | Gross | Frostburg State University |
| Midfield | HM | Kyle | Karsian | Stevenson University |
| Midfield | HM | Jake | Klein | Cabrini University |
| Midfield | HM | Tyler | Kostack | Cabrini University |
| Midfield | HM | Bailey | Marth | Illinois Wesleyan University |
| Midfield | HM | Colin | McGuire | Lynchburg |
| Midfield | HM | Riley | McNulty | U.S. Coast Guard Academy |
| Midfield | HM | Aidan | Milburn | RIT |
| Midfield | HM | Joe | Panariello | Cortland |
| Midfield | HM | Brodie | Phillips | Dickinson College |
| Midfield | HM | Duncan | Preston | Springfield College |
| Midfield | HM | Garrett | Reynolds | Salisbury |
| Midfield | HM | Harry | Rice | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Midfield | HM | Jake | Waxter | Denison |
| Midfield | HM | Nick | Winter | Illinois Wesleyan University |
| Defense | HM | Keaton | Ackermann | RPI |
| Defense | HM | Arend | Broekmate | Tufts |
| Defense | HM | Liam | Burman | Denison |
| Defense | HM | Aaron | Carroll | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Defense | HM | Jake | Cresta | Wesleyan |
| Defense | HM | Daniel | Crotty | Stevens |
| Defense | HM | Tommy | Deluca | Cabrini University |
| Defense | HM | Jack | Doran | Dickinson College |
| Defense | HM | Connor | Eschmann | Springfield College |
| Defense | HM | Rocco | Fantoni | Bates College |
| Defense | HM | Quinn | Fettig | RPI |
| Defense | HM | Patrick | Finneran | Dickinson College |
| Defense | HM | Grant | Garrity | Endicott College |
| Defense | HM | Kyle | Gifford | Washington & Lee |
| Defense | HM | Steven | Gurin | The College at Brockport |
| Defense | HM | Joseph | Hoey | Cabrini University |
| Defense | HM | Austin | Howard | Stevenson University |
| Defense | HM | Jeremy | Klipple | Elizabethtown College |
| Defense | HM | Cullen | Minion | Gettysburg College |
| Defense | HM | Tommy | O’Connor | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Defense | HM | Andres | Rodriguez | Wesleyan |
| Defense | HM | Trevor | Smyth | RIT |
| Defense | HM | Dallas | Creamer | Stevens |
| Defense | HM | Colin | Wharton | Stockton University |
| SSDM | HM | Charlie | DeMuth | Dickinson College |
| SSDM | HM | Hannibal | George | Denison |
| SSDM | HM | Eric | Meyreles | Wesleyan |
| SSDM | HM | Trent | Schulte | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| SSDM | HM | Ben | Tackett | RIT |
| LSM | HM | Cory | Berry | Salisbury |
| LSM | HM | Tyler | Conn | Virginia Wesleyan University |
| LSM | HM | Oskar | Djusberg | Western New England |
| LSM | HM | Seamus | McDonald | Lynchburg |
| LSM | HM | Ben | Shively | Wesleyan |
| Faceoff | HM | Justin | Burnette | Stevenson University |
| Faceoff | HM | Sam | Carlin | Bowdoin College |
| Faceoff | HM | Tony | Cruz | Christopher Newport |
| Faceoff | HM | Henry | DeCamp | Denison |
| Faceoff | HM | Jack | Hodgson | Washington & Lee |
| Faceoff | HM | Ben | Parens | Connecticut College |
| Faceoff | HM | Billy | Sasso | York College of PA |
| Goalie | HM | Otto | Bohan | Wesleyan |
| Goalie | HM | Tim | Brady | Gettysburg College |
| Goalie | HM | Jameal | Hadeed | Eastern |
| Goalie | HM | Trey | Johnson | U.S. Coast Guard Academy |
| Goalie | HM | Steve | Kerr | Western New England |
| Goalie | HM | Sam | Long | Centre College |
| Goalie | HM | Landry | Marshall | York College of PA |
| Goalie | HM | Jake | Reynolds | Springfield College |
| Goalie | HM | Ben | Rigger | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Goalie | HM | Sam | Ross | Stevenson University |
