First Team
| Sophie | Buelow | Lindenwood University | Senior | Midfield |
| Cammy | Case | Queens University of Charlotte | Junior | Defense |
| Bryanna | Fazio | Le Moyne College | Junior | Attack |
| Kelly | Gaffney | Le Moyne College | Senior | Defense |
| Hannah | George | Le Moyne College | Sophomore | Goalkeeper |
| Kallie | German | Rollins College | Junior | Attack |
| Hunter | Isnardi | Mercy College | Junior | Midfield |
| Alison | Johnson | Adelphi University | Sophomore | Attack |
| Sam | Keesey | Florida Southern College | Junior | Defense |
| Krista | Mitarotonda | East Stroudsburg University | Freshman | Attack |
| Meghan | O’Brien | Florida Southern College | Senior | Attack |
| Kole | Pollock | Adelphi University | Sophomore | Attack |
| Mackenzie | Reh | University of New Haven | Junior | Midfield |
| Emily | Santoli | Florida Southern College | Senior | Midfield |
| Talia | Stagnitta | Mercy College | Junior | Defense |
| Maggie | Stella | West Chester University | Junior | Midfield |
Second Team
| Emily | Bitka | Slippery Rock University | Senior | Goalkeeper |
| Jada | Bonner | Regis University | Senior | Midfield |
| Dani | Bursinger | Florida Southern College | Junior | Midfield |
| Allison | Hurley | Lindenwood University | Senior | Attack |
| Taylor | Izzo | Mercyhurst University | Senior | Attack |
| Kira | Kolb | Mercyhurst University | Sophomore | Defense |
| Alyssa | Mallery | Long Island University Post | Sophomore | Midfield |
| Riley | McClure | University of Indianapolis | Sophomore | Defense |
| Olivia | McEntee | Le Moyne College | Sophomore | Defense |
| Alyssa | Milano | New York Inst. of Technology | Senior | Attack |
| Chessie | Rahmer | East Stroudsburg University | Senior | Midfield |
| Michele | Scannell | Adelphi University | Senior | Midfield |
| Samantha | Schiano | Florida Institute of Technology | Junior | Midfield |
| Shannon | Sisk | Limestone College | Senior | Attack |
| Kaitlyn | Stackpole | Adelphi University | Senior | Defense |
| Lauren | Tybor | Florida Institute of Technology | Sophomore | Midfield |
Third Team
| Kristin | Anderson | Mercyhurst University | Senior | Midfield |
| Sami | Barnett | West Chester University | Junior | Midfield |
| Nicole | Delany | Le Moyne College | Sophomore | Midfield |
| Caroline | Dunleavy | Florida Institute of Technology | Senior | Attack |
| Brianna | Feldman | Long Island University Post | Sophomore | Attack |
| Olivia | Going | Florida Institute of Technology | Sophomore | Defense |
| Sara | Grenier | Florida Institute of Technology | Senior | Attack |
| Emily | Jehle | Mercy College | Senior | Attack |
| Olivia | Kirk | Long Island University Post | Senior | Goalkeeper |
| Sarah | Myres | Regis University | Junior | Attack |
| Rachel | Ortell | Lindenwood University | Senior | Goalkeeper |
| Beth Ann | Pierce | Adelphi University | Senior | Midfield |
| Morgan | Reader | Lindenwood University | RS-Sophomore | Defense |
| Emma | Rufolo | East Stroudsburg University | Junior | Midfield |
| Lindsay | Van Beck | Rollins College | Junior | Defense |
| Alyssa | Voccia | Limestone College | Junior | Defense |
