First Team
| Sam | Apuzzo | Boston College | Junior | Attack |
| Dempsey | Arsenault | Boston College | Junior | Midfield |
| Kasey | Behr | University of Virginia | Senior | Midfield |
| Julia | Braig | University of Maryland | Junior | Defense |
| Sarah | Brown | University of Colorado | Senior | Defense |
| Jenna | Collins | US Naval Academy | Senior | Midfield |
| Olivia | Conti | Towson University | Sophomore | Defense |
| Jen | Giles | University of Maryland | Junior | Midfield |
| Katie | Hoeg | University of North Carolina | Sophomore | Attack |
| Julia | Lisella | University of Colorado | RS-Sophomore | Goalkeeper |
| Marie | McCool | University of North Carolina | Senior | Midfield |
| Elizabeth | Miller | Boston College | Junior | Defense |
| Courtney | Murphy | Stony Brook University | Senior | Attack |
| Katie | O’Donnell | Pennsylvania State University | Senior | Midfield |
| Kylie | Ohlmiller | Stony Brook University | Senior | Attack |
| Megan | Whittle | University of Maryland | Senior | Attack |
Second Team
| Erin | Barry | University of Pennsylvania | Sophomore | Midfield |
| Madison | Carter | Pennsylvania State University | Junior | Attack |
| Cassie | Ekstrom | University of Connecticut | Senior | Defense |
| Grace | Gabriel | Marquette University | Junior | Midfield |
| Brooke | Gubitosi | Stony Brook University | RS-Senior | Defense |
| Haley | Hicklen | University of Florida | Junior | Goalkeeper |
| Ally | Kennedy | Stony Brook University | Sophomore | Midfield |
| Darby | Kiernan | University of Colorado | Senior | Attack |
| Kelsey | Murray | Stanford University | RS-Senior | Attack |
| Sheila | Nesselbush | Northwestern University | Senior | Midfield |
| Paige | Petty | Virginia Tech | Freshman | Midfield |
| Lindsey | Ronbeck | University of Florida | Junior | Attack |
| Kyla | Sears | Princeton University | Freshman | Attack |
| Caroline | Steele | University of Maryland | Junior | Attack |
| Cara | Trombetta | University of Florida | Sophomore | Defense |
| Taylor | VanThof | Loyola University | Junior | Midfield |
Third Team
| Kayla | Brisolari | Pennsylvania State University | Junior | Defense |
| Lizzie | Colson | University of Maryland | Sophomore | Defense |
| Kaileen | Hart | Boston College | Senior | Attack |
| Ela | Hazar | University of North Carolina | Senior | Attack |
| Selena | Lasota | Northwestern University | RS Junior | Attack |
| Julia | Massaro | Stanford University | Junior | Defense |
| Kerrigan | Miller | University of Southern California | Sophomore | Midfield |
| Sammy | Mueller | University of Virginia | Sophomore | Midfield |
| Grace | Nolan | University of Connecticut | Senior | Attack |
| Taryn | Ohlmiller | Stony Brook University | Sophomore | Attack |
| Sydney | Pirecca | University of Florida | Junior | Midfield |
| Livy | Rosenzweig | Loyola University | Freshman | Attack |
| Gabby | Rosenzweig | University of Pennsylvania | Sophomore | Attack |
| Megan | Taylor | University of Maryland | Junior | Goalkeeper |
| Holly | Turner | University of Massachusetts | Senior | Attack |
| Tianna | Wallpher | Towson University | Senior | Defense |
