Page 30 of 35

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sat Apr 20, 2024 7:03 pm
by joewillie78
My new top 20, April 20, 2024

1. Notre Dame
2. Johns Hopkins
3. Denver
4. Duke
5. Penn State
6. Syracuse
7. Cornell
8. Yale
9. Virginia
10. Georgetown
11. Maryland
12. Princeton
13. Army
14. St. Joseph
15. Penn
16. Towson
17. Richmond
18. Delaware
19. Villanova
20. Michigan

Gobigred
Joewillie78

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sat Apr 20, 2024 7:44 pm
by Farfromgeneva
joewillie78 wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 7:03 pm My new top 20, April 20, 2024

1. Notre Dame
2. Johns Hopkins
3. Denver
4. Duke
5. Penn State
6. Syracuse
7. Cornell
8. Yale
9. Virginia
10. Georgetown
11. Maryland
12. Princeton
13. Army
14. St. Joseph
15. Penn
16. Towson
17. Richmond
18. Delaware
19. Villanova
20. OSU/Michigan winner.

Gobigred
Joewillie78
You may get a freak out on the GT/ND placement as a heads up.

Have you considered Loyola at all on that back end or so this winning stretch too light on meat for you?

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sat Apr 20, 2024 8:16 pm
by joewillie78
Farfromgeneva wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 7:44 pm
joewillie78 wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 7:03 pm My new top 20, April 20, 2024

1. Notre Dame
2. Johns Hopkins
3. Denver
4. Duke
5. Penn State
6. Syracuse
7. Cornell
8. Yale
9. Virginia
10. Georgetown
11. Maryland
12. Princeton
13. Army
14. St. Joseph
15. Penn
16. Towson
17. Richmond
18. Delaware
19. Villanova
20. OSU/Michigan winner.

Gobigred
Joewillie78
You may get a freak out on the GT/ND placement as a heads up.

Have you considered Loyola at all on that back end or so this winning stretch too light on meat for you?
Yes, I did take a look at Loyola and their resume is getting better but still not superior to the 2 big teams playing tonight. Either winner in my opinion still is a bit ahead of Loyola, but it's close.

Gobigred
Joewillie78

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sat Apr 20, 2024 8:33 pm
by rolldodge
joewillie78 wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 8:16 pm
Farfromgeneva wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 7:44 pm
joewillie78 wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 7:03 pm My new top 20, April 20, 2024

1. Notre Dame
2. Johns Hopkins
3. Denver
4. Duke
5. Penn State
6. Syracuse
7. Cornell
8. Yale
9. Virginia
10. Georgetown
11. Maryland
12. Princeton
13. Army
14. St. Joseph
15. Penn
16. Towson
17. Richmond
18. Delaware
19. Villanova
20. OSU/Michigan winner.

Gobigred
Joewillie78
You may get a freak out on the GT/ND placement as a heads up.

Have you considered Loyola at all on that back end or so this winning stretch too light on meat for you?
Yes, I did take a look at Loyola and their resume is getting better but still not superior to the 2 big teams playing tonight. Either winner in my opinion still is a bit ahead of Loyola, but it's close.

Gobigred
Joewillie78

You might want to take another look. Would like to hear the argument against.

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sat Apr 20, 2024 9:09 pm
by keno in reno
Georgetown has 1 good win (it was Moby Dick but literally that's it). They can't be ahead of Maryland. Yale and Cornell are too high in my mind too, but I'm pleading to the wrong person.

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sat Apr 20, 2024 9:21 pm
by HGK
keno in reno wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 9:09 pm Georgetown has 1 good win (it was Moby Dick but literally that's it). They can't be ahead of Maryland. Yale and Cornell are too high in my mind too, but I'm pleading to the wrong person.
Now do UVA with only one “good” win over Maryland.

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sat Apr 20, 2024 9:39 pm
by rolldodge
keno in reno wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 9:09 pm Georgetown has 1 good win (it was Moby Dick but literally that's it). They can't be ahead of Maryland. Yale and Cornell are too high in my mind too, but I'm pleading to the wrong person.
Maryland’s resume is probably better than Georgetown and not a big fan of eye tests for polls, but eye test: Georgetown is better than Maryland.

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sat Apr 20, 2024 10:35 pm
by Farfromgeneva
rolldodge wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 9:39 pm
keno in reno wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 9:09 pm Georgetown has 1 good win (it was Moby Dick but literally that's it). They can't be ahead of Maryland. Yale and Cornell are too high in my mind too, but I'm pleading to the wrong person.
Maryland’s resume is probably better than Georgetown and not a big fan of eye tests for polls, but eye test: Georgetown is better than Maryland.
Just remember back to your IL #1 recruiting class. Those kids mostly looked like
Thoroughbreads but, oddly for a Urick team, they often played more like
Preening ponies. late In uricks tenure and unfortunately he delegated too much then

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sun Apr 21, 2024 7:32 am
by joewillie78
keno in reno wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 9:09 pm Georgetown has 1 good win (it was Moby Dick but literally that's it). They can't be ahead of Maryland. Yale and Cornell are too high in my mind too, but I'm pleading to the wrong person.
Slotting 6,7,8 was brutal as I believe Cuse is better than both Yale and Cornell BUT Cornell beat Cuse, and Yale has looked great BUT Cornell beat Yale also. Now both of those Cornell wins were at the Kopf, so would those have been W's at Yale and Cuse?

If I just took who beat who, then Cornell should be 6, but again, both were home wins. To me Cornell, Yale and Cuse should be 6a, 6b, 6c as they are that close.

Gobigred
Joewillie78

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sun Apr 21, 2024 9:33 am
by Finster
joewillie78 wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 7:03 pm My new top 20, April 20, 2024

1. Notre Dame
2. Johns Hopkins
3. Denver
4. Duke
5. Penn State
6. Syracuse
7. Cornell
8. Yale
9. Virginia
10. Georgetown
11. Maryland
12. Princeton
13. Army
14. St. Joseph
15. Penn
16. Towson
17. Richmond
18. Delaware
19. Villanova
20. Michigan

Gobigred
Joewillie78



Looks good. I don’t trust Hopkins but I understand why they’re there.

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sun Apr 21, 2024 9:40 am
by joewillie78
Finster wrote: Sun Apr 21, 2024 9:33 am
joewillie78 wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 7:03 pm My new top 20, April 20, 2024

1. Notre Dame
2. Johns Hopkins
3. Denver
4. Duke
5. Penn State
6. Syracuse
7. Cornell
8. Yale
9. Virginia
10. Georgetown
11. Maryland
12. Princeton
13. Army
14. St. Joseph
15. Penn
16. Towson
17. Richmond
18. Delaware
19. Villanova
20. Michigan

Gobigred
Joewillie78



Looks good. I don’t trust Hopkins but I understand why they’re there.
Hopkins to me is one of those teams that doesn't always look pretty, but always seems to find ways to win. They can win with offense, defense, and special teams.

Everytime I watch them and say uh-oh, their in trouble, they turn it around and gut out a win.

Our ex coach has done a fabulous job down on 33rd street.

And as a PS, that freshman defender is as good a young defender as I have seen in a long time.

Gobigred
Joewillie78

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Sun Apr 21, 2024 10:13 am
by coda
joewillie78 wrote: Sun Apr 21, 2024 9:40 am
Finster wrote: Sun Apr 21, 2024 9:33 am
joewillie78 wrote: Sat Apr 20, 2024 7:03 pm My new top 20, April 20, 2024

1. Notre Dame
2. Johns Hopkins
3. Denver
4. Duke
5. Penn State
6. Syracuse
7. Cornell
8. Yale
9. Virginia
10. Georgetown
11. Maryland
12. Princeton
13. Army
14. St. Joseph
15. Penn
16. Towson
17. Richmond
18. Delaware
19. Villanova
20. Michigan

Gobigred
Joewillie78



Looks good. I don’t trust Hopkins but I understand why they’re there.
Hopkins to me is one of those teams that doesn't always look pretty, but always seems to find ways to win. They can win with offense, defense, and special teams.

Everytime I watch them and say uh-oh, their in trouble, they turn it around and gut out a win.

Our ex coach has done a fabulous job down on 33rd street.

And as a PS, that freshman defender is as good a young defender as I have seen in a long time.

Gobigred
Joewillie78
Hopkins is interesting. You could argue they have the best defense in the nation. The offense can run hot and cold at times. The face-off is a weakness. Kind of team that can be playing on Memorial Day weekend, but also enough holes that you could see them vulnerable to an upset.

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Mon Apr 22, 2024 9:07 am
by CU88a
https://www.insidelacrosse.com/article/ ... dame/63155

Men's Division I Media Poll
Rank Team Points Prev
1 Notre Dame (9 - 1) 500 (25) 1
2 Duke (11 - 3) 461 2
3 Johns Hopkins (10 - 3) 446 3
4 Syracuse (11 - 4) 428 6
5 Virginia (10 - 3) 383 4
6 Denver (10 - 2) 347 7
7 Maryland (8 - 4) 333 5
8 Cornell (8 - 4) 323 9
9 Yale (11 - 2) 318 8
10 Penn State (9 - 3) 306 10
11 Georgetown (9 - 3) 266 11
12 Army (10 - 2) 224 12
13 Princeton (8 - 4) 167 17
14 Richmond (9 - 4) 153 15
15 Towson (10 - 3) 151 14
16 Saint Joseph's (9 - 3) 131 16
17 Penn (8 - 5) 126 13
18 Delaware (8 - 3) 71 19
19 Michigan (7 - 6) 36 22
20 Colgate (8 - 5) 21 21

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:25 am
by drunkmonkey30
CU88a wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 9:07 am https://www.insidelacrosse.com/article/ ... dame/63155

Men's Division I Media Poll
Rank Team Points Prev
1 Notre Dame (9 - 1) 500 (25) 1
2 Duke (11 - 3) 461 2
3 Johns Hopkins (10 - 3) 446 3
4 Syracuse (11 - 4) 428 6
5 Virginia (10 - 3) 383 4
6 Denver (10 - 2) 347 7
7 Maryland (8 - 4) 333 5
8 Cornell (8 - 4) 323 9
9 Yale (11 - 2) 318 8
10 Penn State (9 - 3) 306 10
11 Georgetown (9 - 3) 266 11
12 Army (10 - 2) 224 12
13 Princeton (8 - 4) 167 17
14 Richmond (9 - 4) 153 15
15 Towson (10 - 3) 151 14
16 Saint Joseph's (9 - 3) 131 16
17 Penn (8 - 5) 126 13
18 Delaware (8 - 3) 71 19
19 Michigan (7 - 6) 36 22
20 Colgate (8 - 5) 21 21
Can't figure out why the national poles have Virginia so high, especially compared to Cornell.
Common opponents - 'Cuse: Cornell beat, Virginia lost; Harvard: Cornell dominate win, UVA come from behind in Q4. Ohio State: both won.

vs Top 5 RPI: Cornell 1-2; Virginia 0-3

Is it ACC reputation? Cornell's bad showing against Penn State?

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:31 am
by Finster
drunkmonkey30 wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:25 am
CU88a wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 9:07 am https://www.insidelacrosse.com/article/ ... dame/63155

Men's Division I Media Poll
Rank Team Points Prev
1 Notre Dame (9 - 1) 500 (25) 1
2 Duke (11 - 3) 461 2
3 Johns Hopkins (10 - 3) 446 3
4 Syracuse (11 - 4) 428 6
5 Virginia (10 - 3) 383 4
6 Denver (10 - 2) 347 7
7 Maryland (8 - 4) 333 5
8 Cornell (8 - 4) 323 9
9 Yale (11 - 2) 318 8
10 Penn State (9 - 3) 306 10
11 Georgetown (9 - 3) 266 11
12 Army (10 - 2) 224 12
13 Princeton (8 - 4) 167 17
14 Richmond (9 - 4) 153 15
15 Towson (10 - 3) 151 14
16 Saint Joseph's (9 - 3) 131 16
17 Penn (8 - 5) 126 13
18 Delaware (8 - 3) 71 19
19 Michigan (7 - 6) 36 22
20 Colgate (8 - 5) 21 21
Can't figure out why the national poles have Virginia so high, especially compared to Cornell.
Common opponents - 'Cuse: Cornell beat, Virginia lost; Harvard: Cornell dominate win, UVA come from behind in Q4. Ohio State: both won.

vs Top 5 RPI: Cornell 1-2; Virginia 0-3

Is it ACC reputation? Cornell's bad showing against Penn State?



Interesting year. I truly believe any team from 12 to 1 could win this year.

Notre Dame has played so few games on a relative basis, I feel they need to be penalized more than they are.

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:48 am
by BigTurn
Finster wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:31 am
drunkmonkey30 wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:25 am
CU88a wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 9:07 am https://www.insidelacrosse.com/article/ ... dame/63155

Men's Division I Media Poll
Rank Team Points Prev
1 Notre Dame (9 - 1) 500 (25) 1
2 Duke (11 - 3) 461 2
3 Johns Hopkins (10 - 3) 446 3
4 Syracuse (11 - 4) 428 6
5 Virginia (10 - 3) 383 4
6 Denver (10 - 2) 347 7
7 Maryland (8 - 4) 333 5
8 Cornell (8 - 4) 323 9
9 Yale (11 - 2) 318 8
10 Penn State (9 - 3) 306 10
11 Georgetown (9 - 3) 266 11
12 Army (10 - 2) 224 12
13 Princeton (8 - 4) 167 17
14 Richmond (9 - 4) 153 15
15 Towson (10 - 3) 151 14
16 Saint Joseph's (9 - 3) 131 16
17 Penn (8 - 5) 126 13
18 Delaware (8 - 3) 71 19
19 Michigan (7 - 6) 36 22
20 Colgate (8 - 5) 21 21
Can't figure out why the national poles have Virginia so high, especially compared to Cornell.
Common opponents - 'Cuse: Cornell beat, Virginia lost; Harvard: Cornell dominate win, UVA come from behind in Q4. Ohio State: both won.

vs Top 5 RPI: Cornell 1-2; Virginia 0-3

Is it ACC reputation? Cornell's bad showing against Penn State?



Interesting year. I truly believe any team from 12 to 1 could win this year.

Notre Dame has played so few games on a relative basis, I feel they need to be penalized more than they are.
Penalized for what exactly? They have the #2 SOS, #2 RPI, and #1 SOR. All teams control their own schedule, and any team can schedule fewer games if they think it’s such an advantage. Most people were saying this was stupid several years ago when they were left out of the tournament for lack of quality wins, yet now they should be penalized for it?

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:53 am
by HockeyLaxGolf42
1. Notre Dame
2. Hopkins
3. Duke
4. Cuse
5. Denver
6. Virginia
7. Cornell
8. Yale
9. Army
10. Maryland

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:58 am
by Finster
BigTurn wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:48 am
Finster wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:31 am
drunkmonkey30 wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:25 am
CU88a wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 9:07 am https://www.insidelacrosse.com/article/ ... dame/63155

Men's Division I Media Poll
Rank Team Points Prev
1 Notre Dame (9 - 1) 500 (25) 1
2 Duke (11 - 3) 461 2
3 Johns Hopkins (10 - 3) 446 3
4 Syracuse (11 - 4) 428 6
5 Virginia (10 - 3) 383 4
6 Denver (10 - 2) 347 7
7 Maryland (8 - 4) 333 5
8 Cornell (8 - 4) 323 9
9 Yale (11 - 2) 318 8
10 Penn State (9 - 3) 306 10
11 Georgetown (9 - 3) 266 11
12 Army (10 - 2) 224 12
13 Princeton (8 - 4) 167 17
14 Richmond (9 - 4) 153 15
15 Towson (10 - 3) 151 14
16 Saint Joseph's (9 - 3) 131 16
17 Penn (8 - 5) 126 13
18 Delaware (8 - 3) 71 19
19 Michigan (7 - 6) 36 22
20 Colgate (8 - 5) 21 21
Can't figure out why the national poles have Virginia so high, especially compared to Cornell.
Common opponents - 'Cuse: Cornell beat, Virginia lost; Harvard: Cornell dominate win, UVA come from behind in Q4. Ohio State: both won.

vs Top 5 RPI: Cornell 1-2; Virginia 0-3

Is it ACC reputation? Cornell's bad showing against Penn State?
Interesting year. I truly believe any team from 12 to 1 could win this year.

Notre Dame has played so few games on a relative basis, I feel they need to be penalized more than they are.
Penalized for what exactly? They have the #2 SOS, #2 RPI, and #1 SOR. All teams control their own schedule, and any team can schedule fewer games if they think it’s such an advantage. Most people were saying this was stupid several years ago when they were left out of the tournament for lack of quality wins, yet now they should be penalized for it?


It’s a tiny schedule relative to every other team. Throw a few more games on their schedule and who knows what their W-L looks like. Maybe they’d be 12-1. Maybe they’d be 9-4. They got all 25 first place votes. I don’t know how I’d ’penalize’ them. It just doesn’t feel right.

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Mon Apr 22, 2024 11:04 am
by BigTurn
Finster wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:58 am
BigTurn wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:48 am
Finster wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:31 am
drunkmonkey30 wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 10:25 am
CU88a wrote: Mon Apr 22, 2024 9:07 am https://www.insidelacrosse.com/article/ ... dame/63155

Men's Division I Media Poll
Rank Team Points Prev
1 Notre Dame (9 - 1) 500 (25) 1
2 Duke (11 - 3) 461 2
3 Johns Hopkins (10 - 3) 446 3
4 Syracuse (11 - 4) 428 6
5 Virginia (10 - 3) 383 4
6 Denver (10 - 2) 347 7
7 Maryland (8 - 4) 333 5
8 Cornell (8 - 4) 323 9
9 Yale (11 - 2) 318 8
10 Penn State (9 - 3) 306 10
11 Georgetown (9 - 3) 266 11
12 Army (10 - 2) 224 12
13 Princeton (8 - 4) 167 17
14 Richmond (9 - 4) 153 15
15 Towson (10 - 3) 151 14
16 Saint Joseph's (9 - 3) 131 16
17 Penn (8 - 5) 126 13
18 Delaware (8 - 3) 71 19
19 Michigan (7 - 6) 36 22
20 Colgate (8 - 5) 21 21
Can't figure out why the national poles have Virginia so high, especially compared to Cornell.
Common opponents - 'Cuse: Cornell beat, Virginia lost; Harvard: Cornell dominate win, UVA come from behind in Q4. Ohio State: both won.

vs Top 5 RPI: Cornell 1-2; Virginia 0-3

Is it ACC reputation? Cornell's bad showing against Penn State?
Interesting year. I truly believe any team from 12 to 1 could win this year.

Notre Dame has played so few games on a relative basis, I feel they need to be penalized more than they are.
Penalized for what exactly? They have the #2 SOS, #2 RPI, and #1 SOR. All teams control their own schedule, and any team can schedule fewer games if they think it’s such an advantage. Most people were saying this was stupid several years ago when they were left out of the tournament for lack of quality wins, yet now they should be penalized for it?


It’s a tiny schedule relative to every other team. Throw a few more games on their schedule and who knows what their W-L looks like. Maybe they’d be 12-1. Maybe they’d be 9-4. They got all 25 first place votes. I don’t know how I’d ’penalize’ them. It just doesn’t feel right.
Quality > Quantity. They have 2 top 5 wins, 4 top 10 wins and only loss is in OT to current #11. It’s clearly the best resume in the country.

This was masterful scheduling imo. Last year the ring was almost lost to injuries. Corrigan clearly knows what he has and wants to keep the team as healthy as possible. This schedule was not to make the tournament, it was built for another MDW run. Beat the quality teams and you’re rewarded, lose and you’re out, that’s the gamble.

Re: 2024 top 20

Posted: Mon Apr 22, 2024 11:29 am
by NYlax222
Complaining about ND for schedule? hmmm. as others have pointed out, they scheduled teams expected to be top of the BIg10, Ivy, and Big East. Plus of course, the ACC. Let's fault them for not playing LeMoyne, Wagner, Manhattan?