2018 Wesleyan 8–6 Salisbury
2017 Salisbury (12) 15-7 RIT
2016 Salisbury (11) 14-13 Tufts
2015 Tufts (3) 19–11 Lynchburg
2014 Tufts (2) 12–9 Salisbury
2013 Stevenson 16–14 RIT
2012 Salisbury (10) 14–10 SUNY Cortland
2011 Salisbury (9) 19–7 Tufts
2010 Tufts 9–6 Salisbury
2009 SUNY Cortland (2) 9–7 Gettysburg
2008 Salisbury (8) 19–13 SUNY Cortland
2007 Salisbury (7) 15–9 SUNY Cortland
2006 SUNY Cortland 13–12 Salisbury’
2005 Salisbury (6) 11–10 Middlebury
2004 Salisbury (5) 13–9 Nazareth (NY)
2003 Salisbury (4) 14–13 Middlebury
2002 Middlebury (3) 14–9 Gettysburg
2001 Middlebury (2) 15–10 Gettysburg
2000 Middlebury 16–12 Salisbury State
1999 Salisbury State (3) 13–6 Middlebury
1998 Washington College 16–10 Nazareth (NY)
1997 Nazareth (NY) (3) 15–14 Washington College
1996 Nazareth (NY) (2) 11–10 Washington College
1995 Salisbury State (2) 22–13 Nazareth (NY)
1994 Salisbury State 15–9 Hobart
1993 Hobart (13) 16–10 Ohio Wesleyan
1992 Nazareth (NY) 22–11 Roanoke
1991 Hobart (12) 12–11 Salisbury State
1990 Hobart (11) 18–6 Washington College
1989 Hobart (10) 18–9 Ohio Wesleyan
1988 Hobart (9) 18–9 Washington College
1987 Hobart (8) 9–5 Ohio Wesleyan
1986 Hobart (7) 13–10 Washington College
1985 Hobart (6) 15–8 Washington College
1984 Hobart (5) 12–5 Washington College
1983 Hobart (4) 13–9 Roanoke
1982 Hobart (3) 9–8 Washington College
1981 Hobart (2) 10–8 Cortland State
1980 Hobart 11–8 Cortland State